Members

Factoid

Back to homepage

Calvin Johnson: The Sure Thing?

Posted Jun. 05 at 05:31 PM

NFL GMs and draft experts alike are predicting big things from Georgia Tech's Calvin Johnson, who was the first wide receiver taken in the 2007 NFL Draft. A quick look at the history of those guys, however, suggests that not only will he have a fairly modest rookie season -- even 850 receiving yards would establish a high-water mark -- the odds are against him being the type of star player most are projecting.

Even leaving out recent players on whom the jury is still out, nearly two-thirds of the top wideouts drafted since 1967 have gone on to mediocre careers -- at best. Based on recent history, in fact, there's as much chance that Johnson will be with a new team or out of the league 5 years down the road as going to Pro Bowls. This is not to say he won't be a star, of course; just that he'll be in the distinct minority if he turns out that way. And the odds are definitely against him as a rookie: Only 9 of 40 have scored more than 5 TDs in their first season, and only 5 put up more than 800 receiving yards.

The rookie numbers for the top wideouts drafted since 1967 are presented below.

Year RecYds TDs Player, Team
2006 824 2 Santonio Holmes, Pittsburgh
2005 512 3 Braylon Edwards, Cleveland
2004 780 8 Larry Fitzgerald, Arizona
2003 243 3 Charles Rogers, Detroit
2002 594 8 Donte Stallworth, New Orleans
2001 415 4 David Terrell, Chicago
2000 592 7 Peter Warrick, Cincinnati
1999 788 6 Torry Holt, St. Louis
1998 263 2 Kevin Dyson, Tennessee
1997 42 0 Ike Hilliard, NY Giants
1996 844 8 Keyshawn Johnson, NY Jets
1995 522 2 Michael Westbrook, Washington
1994 577 3 Charles Johnson, Pittsburgh
1993 231 2 Curtis Conway, Chicago
1992 20 1 Desmond Howard, Washington
1991 135 0 Herman Moore, Detroit
1990 104 1 Alexander Wright, Dallas
1989 795 5 Hart Lee Dykes, New England
1988 725 7 Tim Brown, LA Raiders
1987 89 0 Haywood Jeffires, Houston
1986 744 5 Mike Sherrard, Dallas
1985 662 3 Al Toon, NY Jets
1984 164 1 Irving Fryar, New England
1983 836 8 Willie Gault, Chicago
1982 116 1 Anthony Hancock, Kansas City
1981 161 2 David Verser, Cincinnati
1980 482 3 Johnny (Lam) Jones, NY Jets
1979 834 4 Jerry Butler, Buffalo
1978 472 2 Wes Chandler, New Orleans
1977 443 3 Stanley Morgan, New England
1976 191 0 Billy Brooks, Cincinnati
1975 305 2 Larry Burton, New Orleans
1974 208 3 Lynn Swann, Pittsburgh
1973 843 9 Isaac Curtis, Cincinnati
1972 500 3 Ahmad Rashad, St. Louis
1971 216 2 J.D. Hill, Buffalo
1970 196 2 Ken Burrough, New Orleans
1969 705 6 Ron Sellers, Boston
1968 633 2 Haven Moses, Buffalo
1967 711 2 Gene Washington, Minnesota

Source: FANTASY FOOTBALL INDEX research

Readers' Comments

Posted by ANDY RICHARDSON | Jun. 07 at 05:32 AM

Odds may be against him, but it won't matter. Guy is going to be a superstar. Matt Millen gets lucky.

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly

Fantasy Football Index 2008 is AVAILABLE NOW!

Fantasy Football Index includes 220 pages of player ratings, team analysis, stat projections, defensive player analysis, unique stat charts, sleeper picks, rule suggestions, offensive line analysis, and more. And don't forget to order your Fantasy Index Cheat Sheet Updates so they'll be ready and waiting when it's time for your draft or auction.

Sign up now and rule your draft with Fantasy Index Cheat Sheet Updates.

Subscribe now.

Past Articles

Toolbox