Members

Fantasy News


Back to homepage

Experts Poll: Kevin Marshall wins wide receivers

Posted Jan. 27 at 02:30 AM

Continuing with the grading of the Fantasy Index Experts Poll, some new faces have popped up. Kevin Marshall of Draftwizard.com is the winner in the wide receiver category, followed by Colin Darlington of MyStartEmSitEm.com.

James Serra of First Place Sports Software, meanwhile, remains the overall leader, with a lead of 1,153 points over Scott Pianowski (Yahoo! Sports). David Dorey (The Huddle), who finished 3rd in the wide receiver category, and Rick Hawes (Fanball) are about another 500 points back.

At wide receiver, Marshall didn’t make any one pick that gave him a huge advantage, but put together a well-rounded card. He was among the highest on Wes Welker (12th), Brandon Marshall (11th), Vincent Jackson (14th) and DeSean Jackson (18th). Those picks all helped him. And he was among the lowest on Steve Smith (8th), Terrell Owens (15th) and T.J. Houshmandzadeh (17th). Those picks all helped him relative to the other experts.

In this competition, every pick – 120 for each of the experts – is graded, with players receiving more credit the higher they are ranked. Marshall went with Larry Fitzgerald as his No. 1 wide receiver; that pick was worth 3,744 points (20 x 187.2). He went with Andre Johnson No. 2; that pick was worth 4,064 points (19 x 213.9). Follow that process for every pick by every expert and Marshall is the winner in this category.

The fantasy scoring system here is 6 points for TDs, 4 for TD passes, 1 for every 10 run/rec yards and 1 for every 20 passing yards.

When the scoring is done for all six positions, the top 11 finishers will win spots in our Mock Draft league (with the No. 1 finisher getting to choose where he would like to select). That field should be set in a few days.

The Fantasy Index picks aren't included in these results. Out of fairness to the competition, we stay in the administrator role. (Most notably, our picks aren't locked into the same deadline, which usually is around May 20.) But if you plug in our magazine picks, which are printed in early June, we would have fared poorly at the wide receiver position – as in 500 points behind every other expert. That’s almost solely due to Anthony Gonzalez getting hurt early in the first game of the season. We had Gonzalez 9th, while only three other experts even snuck him into the bottom of their top 20. In this scoring system, team health is crucial (since you’re not allowed to submit lineups or make waiver moves), and one injury can change everything. Had Gonzalez stayed healthy and done what we thought he would (1,100 yards and 8 TDs), we would have finished 2nd relative to the 20 experts.



FANTASY INDEX EXPERTS POLL: WIDE RECEIVERS

  Points  
  34,246  Kevin Marshall
  34,169  Colin Darlington
  33,793  David Dorey
  33,740  Nathan Zegura
  33,647  Pretzel May
  33,596  James Serra
  33,580  Christopher Harris
  33,515  Scott Pianowski
  33,505  Scott Endsley
  33,374  Sam Hendricks
  33,345  Michael Nazarek
  33,210  Bob Henry
  33,162  Rick Hawes
  33,058  Jeffrey Kamys
  32,988  Cory Bonini
  32,937  Alan Satterlee
  32,837  Bo Mitchell
  32,654  Chris Liss
  32,646  Louis Tranquilli
  32,616  Lenny Pappano




FANTASY INDEX EXPERTS POLL: OVERALL (so far)
(Includes WR, TE, K, Def)

  Points  
  112,696  James Serra
  111,543  Scott Pianowski
  111,028  David Dorey
  110,919  Rick Hawes
  110,748  Pretzel May
  110,518  Chris Liss
  110,488  Christopher Harris
  110,326  Nathan Zegura
  110,137  Kevin Marshall
  110,026  Colin Darlington
  109,991  Sam Hendricks
  109,897  Alan Satterlee
  109,851  Michael Nazarek
  109,780  Bob Henry
  109,273  Jeffrey Kamys
  108,977  Scott Endsley
  108,854  Louis Tranquilli
  108,802  Lenny Pappano
  108,563  Bo Mitchell
  107,954  Cory Bonini



MULTIPLIER NUMBERS FOR WIDE RECEIVERS
Using the scoring system of 6 points for TDs and 1 for every 10 yards:

  Points  
  213.9  Andre Johnson
  206.4  Randy Moss
  202.4  DeSean Jackson
  187.2  Larry Fitzgerald
  186.4  Reggie Wayne
  181.5  Roddy White
  175.9  Brandon Marshall
  171.8  Vincent Jackson
  162.4  Wes Welker
  162.0  Marques Colston
  161.9  Chad Ochocinco
  155.4  Santonio Holmes
  152.7  Hines Ward
  144.4  Steve Smith
  139.3  Greg Jennings
  135.7  Calvin Johnson
  133.6  Anquan Boldin
  124.3  Terrell Owens
  109.1  T.J. Houshmandzadeh
  109.0  Santana Moss
  103.2  Lee Evans
  101.6  Roy Williams
    94.0  Braylon Edwards
    85.8  Bernard Berrian
    84.0  Antonio Bryant
    82.9  Dwayne Bowe
    72.2  Torry Holt
    68.2  Ted Ginn
    46.5  Eddie Royal
    27.3  Lance Moore
    00.0  Anthony Gonzalez


—Ian Allan

Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Football Index

Order Fantasy Football Index!

Cheaters Always Prosper! Prepare for your draft with the original and best fantasy football study guide. Fantasy Football Index magazine includes nearly 200 pages of cheat sheets, depth charts, mock drafts, team-by-team and position-by-position breakdowns, rookie ratings, 2012 stats and 2013 stat projections.

Subscribe now.


Fantasy Football Index

Past Articles

More

Toolbox