Members

Factoid


Back to homepage

First-round quarterbacks in Super Bowls

Posted Feb. 06 at 10:52 PM

Everyone’s always saying that the NFL is a quarterback-driven sport. That’s supposedly the position that you have to fill, therefore, with an early pick in the first round.

And if you have the chance to select a player like Peyton Manning, Ben Roethlisberger, Tom Brady or Brett Favre with the No. 1 pick of a draft, that’s certainly a nice way to go.

The problem, of course, is that a lot of those first-round quarterbacks don’t pan out. And even good players can’t do it by themselves; they need a solid supporting cast.

In the last 20 years, in fact, only four Super Bowls have featured matchups between two quarterbacks selected in the first round.

1992  Troy Aikman (Dall.) vs. Jim Kelly (Buff.)

1993  Troy Aikman (Dall.) vs. Jim Kelly (Buff.)

2000  Trent Dilfer (Balt.) vs. Kerry Collins (NYG)

2006  Peyton Manning (Ind.) vs. Rex Grossman (Chic.)


This year’s game comes close. Manning was the No. 1 overall pick in 1998. Drew Brees was the first pick of the 2nd round in 2001 – that was the year that San Diego traded down with the Falcons, who selected Michael Vick.

Also note that for the 2000 game, both quarterbacks were originally selected by other teams. The Buccaneers drafted Dilfer, and the Panthers picked Collins.

—Ian Allan


Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly

The Week 1 Fantasy Index Weekly is available now!

-- Notes for all 32 teams.
-- Analysis of all 16 games.
-- Forecasts for how every player will do in this week's games


Pick better starters with our weekend matchup preview. Learn which top players may be shut down and which sleepers may overachieve this week. Revised player rankings for each week's games for three scoring systems. One extra win per season may be the difference between finishing in the money and missing the playoffs.

Buy the Fantasy Index Weekly | Log In


Weekly


September 8 Cheat Sheet Update is available

Get our latest cheat sheets, including rankings and auction values customized for your league. Plus: Team-by-team analysis, depth charts, stat projections and defensive player analysis and printer-friendly PDF cheat sheets that print on a single page.

Buy Cheat Sheet Update | See a sample | Log In


Cheat Sheet

Past Articles

More

Toolbox