Members

Factoid


Back to homepage

Is the Giants defense overrated?

Posted Sep. 11 at 11:59 AM

The New York Giants have a great reputation on defense. It’s a unit that’s helped them win two Super Bowls in the last five years. It came up big in both of those games, and also contributed to big wins on the road to get to those games.

It’s a group with a bunch of great pass rushers – Jason Tuck, Osi Umenyiora, Jason Pierre-Paul.

But is the actually a true, elite unit?

More specifically, is it a unit we should all be avoiding when submitting fantasy lineups? If you have Doug Martin this week, for example, do you hold him out to avoid having him running against the Giants?

The numbers say no. Hell no, in fact.

Only once in the last nine years have the Giants ranked better than 14th in scoring defense. In five of the past six years, they’ve been below-average.

During their current five-year run, with the two Super Bowls, only eight teams have allowed more points than the Giants.

It’s a unit, apparently, with a knack for coming up big in specific postseason games. It’s come up big at the key times on the big stage.

But this is not a great unit that we should be avoiding over a 17-week regular season.

BEST DEFENSES, LAST FIVE YEARS
(Average points per game since 2007).
   Points   
   15.9   Pittsburgh
   17.8   Baltimore
   19.0   New England
   19.6   Green Bay
   19.9   Tennessee
   20.0   San Francisco
   20.1   NY Jets
   20.4   Philadelphia
   20.6   San Diego
   21.1   Indianapolis
   21.1   Washington
   21.3   Chicago
   21.3   Atlanta
   21.5   Dallas
   21.8   Cleveland
   21.9   Minnesota
   22.0   Cincinnati
   22.1   New Orleans
   22.4   Miami
   22.4   Seattle
   22.5   Jacksonville
   22.6   Tampa Bay
   22.7   Houston
   22.7   NY Giants
   22.8   Carolina
   23.3   Kansas City
   23.5   Buffalo
   24.1   Arizona
   24.6   Oakland
   25.5   Denver
   25.9   St. Louis
   27.6   Detroit

—Ian Allan


Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Football Index

Order Fantasy Football Index!

Cheaters Always Prosper! Prepare for your draft with the original and best fantasy football study guide. Fantasy Football Index magazine includes nearly 200 pages of cheat sheets, depth charts, mock drafts, team-by-team and position-by-position breakdowns, rookie ratings, 2012 stats and 2013 stat projections.

Subscribe now.


Fantasy Football Index

Past Articles

More

Toolbox