Members

Fantasy News

Back to homepage

Fanex: Mulling a one-kicker offense

Posted May. 31 at 12:06 PM

I made a somewhat lopsided trade in the Fanex competition. I traded away pick 16.05 to move up to 16.02. And to get that deal done, I moved down from 17.08 to 20.02. So that’s 3 picks for almost 3 rounds, which I’ll admit seems a little strange.

My thinking is that with the kicker run well under way, I want to go out and grab the one kicker on the board that I am shocked hasn’t been selected – Nate Kaeding. He’s a great kicker, and I fear that one of these teams right ahead of me is going to grab him. He’s very accurate (just 3 misses three years in a row), plays for a very good team, and the Chargers have an easy schedule this year (did I mention that I did an extensive study of strength of schedule for the magazine?).

Kaeding might also buy me an extra roster spot. With him in the fold, I will consider carrying only one kicker on my roster, creating a spot for an additional roll-of-the-dice player in round 20 if there’s someone on the board I like. That is a risky course of action; if Kaeding gets hurt, I would be left taking zeros at that position. But sometimes, the guys who take the risks walk away the big winners.

I did some research on the value of the second kicker (and remember, this is a best-ball league). If we assume that Kaeding again will score 118 points (I actually think he’ll score a few more) and we assume that the second kicker I would draft, early in the last round, would score 109-110 points, then we can use last year’s kickers to estimate what I would be missing out on. Using the week-by-week data for those guys (versus Kaeding), I would project to lose 24, 50, 41, or 31 points.

I’ll continue to mull that one over. I’m not sure if I’ll go with the one-kicker approach or not. Your opinions, of course, are welcome.


Here’s where the draft stands now, with 193 of 240 players selected.

Fanex Football Experts Draft
1.01 RB SD LaDainian Tomlinson (Nazarek)
1.02 RB MIN Adrian Peterson (Cannon)
1.03 RB IND Joseph Addai (Hickerson)
1.04 RB PHI Brian Westbrook (Georgopoulus)
1.05 RB STL Steven Jackson (Allan, trade)
1.06 RB SF Frank Gore (O'Leary)
1.07 RB BUF Marshawn Lynch (Dolfi)
1.08 RB BAL Willis McGahee (Butler, trade)
1.09 RB KC Larry Johnson (Cahill)
1.10 RB WAS Clinton Portis (Kellogg)
1.11 RB DAL Marion Barber (Pitzer)
1.12 RB GB Ryan Grant (Holm)
2.01 WR NE Randy Moss (Holm)
2.02 RB NO Reggie Bush (Pitzer)
2.03 RB MIA Ronnie Brown (Kellogg)
2.04 QB NE Tom Brady (Cahill)
2.05 RB TEN LenDale White (Butler, trade)
2.06 RB JAC Maurice Jones-Drew (Dolfi)
2.07 RB CLE Jamal Lewis (O'Leary)
2.08 QB IND Peyton Manning (Cannon, trade)
2.09 WR IND Reggie Wayne (Georgopoulus)
2.10 RB NE Laurence Maroney (Hickerson)
2.11 WR DAL Terrell Owens (Cannon, trade)
2.12 RB ARI Edgerrin James (Nazarek)
3.01 RB ATL Michael Turner (Nazarek)
3.02 WR HOU Andre Johnson (Allan, trade)
3.03 WR CLE Braylon Edwards (Hickerson)
3.04 WR NO Marques Colston (Georgopoulus)
3.05 TE SD Antonio Gates (Butler)
3.06 WR ARI Larry Fitzgerald (O'Leary)
3.07 WR CIN T.J. Houshmandzadeh (Dolfi)
3.08 WR CAR Steve Smith (Allan, trade)
3.09 WR ARI Anquan Boldin (Cahill)
3.10 QB DAL Tony Romo (Kellogg)
3.11 WR CIN Chad Johnson (Pitzer)
3.12 RB PIT Willie Parker (Holm)
4.01 RB OAK Darren McFadden (Holm)
4.02 WR STL Torry Holt (Pitzer)
4.03 WR DEN Brandon Marshall (Kellogg)
4.04 RB TB Earnest Graham (Cahill)
4.05 WR NE Wes Welker (Allan)
4.06 RB NYG Brandon Jacobs (Dolfi)
4.07 RB CIN Rudi Johnson (O'Leary)
4.08 RB NYJ Thomas Jones (Georgopoulus)
4.09 QB CIN Carson Palmer (Hickerson)
4.10 WR NYG Plaxico Burress (Cannon)
4.11 QB NO Drew Brees (Butler)
4.12 WR DET Roy Williams (Nazarek)
5.01 TE DAL Jason Witten (Nazarek)
5.02 RB CHI Matt Forte (Allan, trade)
5.03 WR IND Marvin Harrison (Hickerson)
5.04 WR PIT Hines Ward (Georgopoulus)
5.05 QB HOU Matt Schaub (Butler)
5.06 TE KC Tony Gonzalez (O'Leary)
5.07 TE CLE Kellen Winslow (Dolfi)
5.08 WR DET Calvin Johnson (Allan)
5.09 WR KC Dwayne Bowe (Cahill)
5.10 RB DEN Travis Henry (Kellogg)
5.11 QB CLE Derek Anderson (Dolfi, trade)
5.12 RB SEA Julius Jones (Holm)
6.01 WR PIT Santonio Holmes (Holm)
6.02 QB PIT Ben Roethlisberger (Pitzer)
6.03 WR BUF Lee Evans (Kellogg)
6.04 WR GB Greg Jennings (Cahill)
6.05 RB DET Kevin Smith (Allan)
6.06 QB SEA Matt Hasselbeck (Pitzer, trade)
6.07 WR ATL Roddy White (O'Leary)
6.08 TE WAS Chris Cooley (Butler)
6.09 RB CAR DeAngelo Williams (Georgopoulus)
6.10 WR IND Anthony Gonzalez (Hickerson)
6.11 WR SD Chris Chambers (Cannon)
6.12 QB PHI Donovan McNabb (Nazarek)
7.01 WR BAL Derrick Mason (Nazarek)
7.02 RB CAR Jonathan Stewart (Cannon)
7.03 RB JAC Fred Taylor (Hickerson)
7.04 QB NYG Eli Manning (Georgopoulus)
7.05 WR TB Joey Galloway (Butler)
7.06 QB STL Marc Bulger (O'Leary)
7.07 WR PHI Kevin Curtis (Pitzer, trade)
7.08 TE IND Dallas Clark (Cannon, trade)
7.09 RB PIT Rashard Mendenhall (Cahill)
7.10 WR GB Donald Driver (Kellogg)
7.11 QB DEN Jay Cutler (Allan, trade)
7.12 WR NYJ Jerricho Cotchery (Holm)
8.01 WR MIN Bernard Berrian (Holm)
8.02 WR WAS Santana Moss (Dolfi, trade)
8.03 RB DAL Felix Jones (Kellogg)
8.04 RB NO Deuce McAllister (Cahill)
8.05 RB HOU Ahman Green (Pitzer, trade)
8.06 WR NYJ Laveranues Coles (Dolfi)
8.07 WR OAK Javon Walker (O'Leary)
8.08 WR PIT Limas Sweed (Butler)
8.09 WR SEA Deion Branch (Georgopoulus)
8.10 WR PHI Reggie Brown (Hickerson)
8.11 WR SEA Bobby Engram (Cannon)
8.12 WR SEA Nate Burleson (Nazarek)
9.01 RB MIN Chester Taylor (Nazarek)
9.02 RB CHI Cedric Benson (Cannon)
9.03 TE NYG Jeremy Shockey (Hickerson)
9.04 TE TEN Alge Crumpler (Georgopoulus)
9.05 WR PHI DeSean Jackson (Butler)
9.06 RB DET Tatum Bell (O'Leary)
9.07 QB JAC David Garrard (Allan)
9.08 RB HOU Chris Brown (Cahill)
9.09 WR DAL Patrick Crayton (Dolfi)
9.10 RB ATL Jerious Norwood (Kellogg)
9.11 WR BAL Mark Clayton (Pitzer)
9.12 QB TEN Vince Young (Holm)
10.01 QB GB Aaron Rodgers (Holm)
10.02 RB GB Brandon Jackson (Pitzer)
10.03 QB ARI Matt Leinart (Kellogg)
10.04 WR SF Isaac Bruce (Cahill)
10.05 TE HOU Owen Daniels (Pitzer, trade)
10.06 TE BAL Todd Heap (Dolfi)
10.07 QB CAR Jake Delhomme (O'Leary)
10.08 QB SD Philip Rivers (Butler)
10.10 RB TEN Chris Johnson (Hickerson)
10.11 RB DEN Selvin Young (Cannon)
10.12 QB DET Jon Kitna (Nazarek)
11.01 WR NE Jabar Gaffney (Nazarek)
11.02 WR BUF James Hardy (Cannon)
11.03 QB WAS Jason Campbell (Hickerson)
11.04 QB BUF Trent Edwards (Georgopoulus)
11.06 WR JAC Jerry Porter (O'Leary)
11.07 RB NYG Ahmad Bradshaw (Allan, trade)
11.08 TE SF Vernon Davis (Allan)
11.09 WR CLE Donte Stallworth (Cahill)
11.10 WR OAK Drew Carter (Kellogg)
11.11 TE NE Benjamin Watson (Pitzer)
11.12 RB OAK Justin Fargas (Holm)
12.01 QB MIN Tarvaris Jackson (Holm)
12.02 RB TB Warrick Dunn (Pitzer)
12.03 QB SF Alex Smith (Kellogg)
12.04 RB MIA Ricky Williams (Cahill)
12.05 WR SF Bryant Johnson (Allan)
12.06 WR CAR D.J. Hackett (Dolfi)
12.07 RB SF DeShaun Foster (O'Leary)
12.08 RB SEA T.J. Duckett (Butler)
12.09 WR DEN Darrell Jackson (Georgopoulus)
12.10 RB BAL Ray Rice (Hickerson)
12.11 DEF SD San Diego (Cannon)
12.12 TE PHI L.J. Smith (Nazarek)
13.01 DEF NE New England (Nazarek)
13.02 QB TB Jeff Garcia (Cannon)
13.03 WR MIN Sidney Rice (Hickerson)
13.04 RB TB Cadillac Williams (Georgopoulus)
13.05 QB OAK JaMarcus Russell (Cahill, trade)
13.06 DEF CHI Chicago (O'Leary)
13.07 RB OAK Michael Bush (Dolfi)
13.08 TE PIT Heath Miller (Allan)
13.09 RB PHI Correll Buckhalter (Butler, trade)
13.10 TE DEN Tony Scheffler (Kellogg)
13.12 DEF NYG NY Giants (Dolfi, trade)
13.12 WR SD Vincent Jackson (Holm)
14.01 TE GB Donald Lee (Holm)
14.02 WR OAK Ronald Curry (Pitzer)
14.03 TE STL Randy McMichael (Kellogg)
14.04 WR NO Devery Henderson (Butler, trade)
14.05 WR MIA Ernest Wilford (Allan)
14.06 RB BUF Fred Jackson (Dolfi)
14.07 DEF PIT Pittsburgh (O'Leary)
14.08 PK IND Adam Vinatieri (Butler)
14.09 RB NE Sammy Morris (Nazarek, trade)
14.10 DEF DAL Dallas (Hickerson)
14.11 PK DAL Nick Folk (Cannon)
14.12 WR STL Drew Bennett (Georgopoulus, trade)
15.01 DEF BAL Baltimore (Georgopoulus, trade)
15.02 PK NE Stephen Gostkowski (Cannon)
15.03 DEF MIN Minnesota (Hickerson)
15.04 WR HOU Kevin Walter (Nazarek, trade)
15.05 PK CIN Shayne Graham (Butler)
15.06 PK GB Mason Crosby (O'Leary)
15.07 QB CLE Brady Quinn (Dolfi)
15.08 TE CHI Greg Olsen (Allan)
15.09 WR JAC Reggie Williams (Cahill)
15.10 WR NO Robert Meachem (Kellogg)
15.11 RB HOU Steve Slaton (Pitzer)
15.12 WR TEN Justin Gage (Holm)
16.01 TE OAK Zach Miller (Holm)
16.02 PK SD Nate Kaeding (Allan, trade)
16.03 WR MIA Ted Ginn (Kellogg)
16.04 TE CHI Desmond Clark (Cahill)
16.05 QB ARI Kurt Warner (Pitzer, trade)
16.06 RB KC Kolby Smith (Dolfi)
16.07 PK ARI Neil Rackers (O'Leary)
16.08 DEF JAC Jacksonville (Butler)
16.09 TE CAR Jeff King (Georgopoulus)
16.10 PK STL Josh Brown (Hickerson)
16.11 RB CIN Kenny Watson (Cannon)
16.12 QB KC Brodie Croyle (Nazarek)
17.01 WR NO David Patten (Nazarek)
17.02 PK CHI Robbie Gould (Cannon)
17.03 PK TEN Rob Bironas (Hickerson)
17.04 RB NYJ Leon Washington (Georgopoulus)
17.05 DEF CIN Cincinnati (Butler)
17.06 WR CHI Mark Bradley (O'Leary)
17.08 DEF IND Indianapolis (Pitzer, trade)
17.09 DEF CLE Cleveland (Kellogg)
17.09 TE JAC Marcedes Lewis (Cahill)
17.11 DEF TEN Tennessee (Pitzer)
17.12 PK HOU Kris Brown (Holm)
18.01 PK JAC Josh Scobee (Holm)


The scoring system for this league is 6 points for TDs, 4 for TD passes, 1 point per reception, 1 point for every 20 passing yards and 1 point for every 10 run/rec yards. Teams start 3 WR, 2 RB, QB, TE, PK, DEF and one flex (WR-RB-TE) player. 18-man rosters. No waiver moves. No lineups (it's a best-ball format). High score after 17 NFL weeks wins.

To read the writeups on the picks in the 2008 draft (where each expert explains his picks) click here.

The most up-to-date info on the Fanex League can be accessed at www.myfantasyleague.com.

—Ian Allan

Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly

The August 25 Cheat Sheet Update is available now

Get our latest cheat sheets, including rankings and auction values customized for your league. Plus: Team-by-team analysis, depth charts, stat projections and defensive player analysis and printer-friendly PDF cheat sheets that print on a single page.

Buy Cheat Sheet Update | See a sample | Log In


Cheat Sheet


Fantasy Football Index 2008 is AVAILABLE NOW!

Fantasy Football Index includes 220 pages of player ratings, team analysis, stat projections, defensive player analysis, unique stat charts, sleeper picks, rule suggestions, offensive line analysis, and more.

Get yours now.

Past Articles

Toolbox