Fantasy Index

Fantasy News

Changes coming to custom scoring

Will including extra options for defenses

How likely is a team to get a shutout? What if it's a good defense? Ian Allan spent most of the day researching defensive performance, and his findings will be worked in the custom scoring engine for defenses.

I've gotten some emails from readers asking about defensive scoring. So I spent most of today working on it.

I took the week-by-week data from the last 11 seasons. That's 352 defenses. Then I separated them out into groups, based on their overall performance. A nut-tough defense like Seattle or San Francisco, after all, is far more likely to hold an opponent to 0, 3 or 10 points then a lesser unit like Philadelphia or Oakland.

We already project average points per game allowed by each defense. Andy Richardson takes first crack at those, then I chime in with my opinions on the units that I think he's got too high or too low, and we work it out. Now we can use those projections to tie into fantasy scoring systems that include bonuses for limiting scoring by opponents.

I believe, for example, that Andy has Seattle projected to allow about 17 points per game. According to this study I just completed, when you have a defense that's allows 17.0 to 17.9 points per game, those defenses on any given week have a 3.1 percent chance of getting a shutout, a 4.5 percent chance of allowing 3 points, a 4.8 percent chance of allowing 6 points, a 6.3 percent chance of allowing 9 points, etc.

So in your league, if a defense gets 10 points for each shutout, that will add 4.96 points to Seattle's projected fantasy points (3.1% x 16 games x 10 points).

You follow the same process for all of the game probabilities, and you've got an accurate fantasy projection, helping you place the correct value on your fantasy defenses.

This isn't a huge deal in some fantasy scoring systems. It depends on how much you reward defenses for the different thresholds. But it's something I've been meaning to do, and today I got around to it.

I pass along the proposal to our programmer. I imagine he'll be able to get this implemented by next week.

-- Ian Allan

4 Reader Comments:

Andy Whaley

LA VISTA, NE
2013-08-15T22:32:15Z
I have always wondered about this aspect. I'm glad you guys have taken an interest into exploring this more since all of my leagues take the defenses opponent's score into account when scoring the defense. We even add 5 extra points for the defensive team winning in some leagues. Thanks for continuing to change you projections to become even better as time passes us by!

ROBERT JOHNSON

PEARLAND, TX
2013-08-16T18:07:03Z
Thanks Guys! Our leagues have have had a points allowed scoring category for years. In addition to awarding points for a shutout, we have a sliding scale for 0-6 points allowed, 7-13 points allowed, and 14-19 points allowed. 20 or more points allowed = 0. The only big debate about this approach over the years is the unfairness of having the opponent's defense sore, and having that count in the point total. There have been periodic attmepts to amend our scoring system to recognize 'offensive points scored' only, but it has always been voted down.

ROBERT JOHNSON

PEARLAND, TX
2013-08-16T18:14:37Z
Another note: We also give points to our defenses on a sliding scale for rushing yards allowed, and passing yards allowed. We award 2 points per sack, and 5 points per interception. In most years, top defenses in our leagues (an annual draft PPR, Distance and Yardage League, and a Dynasty League with the same scoring system) rival the top QBs in total points scored. We like this, because, after all, whenever you are watching football, defense is half the equation! None of this 'take only one defense in the latter stages of your draft' nonsense for us!

ROBERT JOHNSON

PEARLAND, TX
2013-08-16T18:18:06Z
Last but not least, to give everyone the full picture (and hopefully something to think about) we draft return teams separately, and have our own point categories for them (Carries, yardage and scores). We have never believed that defenses and return teams should be lumped together in fantasy football -- two very different creatures.
Sign in to add a comment

Fantasy Index