Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Fantasy News

Fantasy Index Open (overall)

Tom Deskovitz wins it all

Advertising executive from Michigan is winner of 2013 all-comers Fantasy Index Open. Josh Gordon was his big pick. Michael Livengood from Arkansas is also living good, with runnerup spot.

Tom Deskovitz, an advertising executive from South Lyon, Mich., is the overall champion of the 2013 Fantasy Index Open. He was able to outperform 208 other contestents to win it.

Deskovitz’s big pick was Josh Gordon, who had a breakout season for the Browns. Only a handful of experts included Gordon on their draft board. Deskovitz put him up at 13th, helping him to about a 4,000-point advantage over most of the field.

With the rest of his picks, Deskovitz just had to perform well enough to hang onto that lead. He finished a below-average 131st in defenses. He was in the top 25 percent at kickers. He finished 71st at tight end and 87th at running back (so, about in the top third at those positions).

Ultimately, it came down to quarterbacks. Deskovitz was able to cobble together an 18th-place finish at that position, helping him nose ahead of a a handful of other competitors.

Deskovitz wins an enomorous trophy from the crew at Affordable Trophies. To help promote this contest, they gratiously offer to supply a trophy for the winner.

Michael Livengood, a newspaper designer from Ward, Arkansas, is the 2nd-place finisher. He wins a berth in the regular Experts Poll that will appear in the 2014 edition of Fantasy Football Index – he and Deskovitz will compete there against 18 industry experts from around the country, with picks due in late May.

Dana Duffield, an engineer from Rochester, Minn., finished in 3rd, and his entry might have been the most impressive of all. I have mentioned multiple times the pros and cons of the 30-11 and 20-1 scoring systems, which were a factor at multiple positions. Duffield would be the winner in the old-style scoring system (which puts a higher premium on the picks at the top of the board). Only two other guys ranked in the top 10 using both scoring systems. Steve Moyer, an investment realtor from Alameda, Calif., finished 4th in the official scoring and 10th in the old-school scoring. Livengood finished 2nd and 7th.

Deskovitz is the winner, but he would have been just 16th in our former scoring system (where he would have gotten a lot less credit for the Josh Gordon pick).

Thank you to all who particpated. The 2014 competition will be similar – picks will be due prior to the start of the first preseason game. The scoring system is up for discussion, and you’re welcome to add your thoughts below. We’ve tried 20-1 and we’re tried 30-11; I believe it will be 25-6 next time around.

Here are your top 20 finishers – the top 10 percent. For these results, I used a sliding scale of 30-11 when multiplying out where a player rated.

FANTASY INDEX OPEN (Top 25 - official)
RankNameHometownOccupationPoints
1Tom DeskovitzSouth Lyon, Mich.Advertising Executive393,916
2Michael LivengoodWard, Ark.Newspaper designer393,379
3Dana DuffieldRochester, Minn.Engineer393,042
4Steve MoyerAlameda, Calif.Investment Realtor392,817
5Tom OverbergerBedminster, Pa.Guidance Counselor392,708
6Jamie AlbertsSturgeon Bay, Wis.Banker391,938
7Aaron SucovMonmouth Junction, N.J.Student391,650
8Derek MathisNorth Charleston, S.C.Insurance Salesman391,647
9John D. SmithMount Laurel, N.J.Warehouse Manager390,809
10Doug PawlakKnoxville, Tenn.Engineer390,751
11Scott LilesRussellville, Ark.Gentleman Adventurer390,725
12Dean TuffieAliquippa, Pa.Accountant390,670
13S. LindMonmouth Junction, N.J.Doctor390,659
14Stephen MckenzieRed Wing, Minn.Books Are Fun Sales Rep390,413
15Mike ClayFleetwood, Pa.Fantasy Football Writer390,338
16Juan NovoMiami, Fla.Sales390,177
17Curt GoldgrabeBoise, IdahoExecutive Director390,107
18Zach LeavittHighlands Ranch, Colo.Accountant390,012
19Mike BallietMilton, Pa.Laborer389,848
20Joseph MichelangeloOceanside, N.Y.Consultant389,758
21Mike CarlsonSacramento, Calif.Fantasy Football Pro389,652
22Brant HollenbeckLansing, Mich.Sales389,643
23Mike NeaseWest Chicago, Ill.Fantasy Football Writer389,523
24Scott BradyCollegeville, Pa.Contract Administrator389,418
25Bradley WolfrumAlpharetta, Ga.Small Business Owner389,411

Here are the top 25 using the scoring system with a sliding scale of 20-1 points (more weight on the picks at the top of the board).

FANTASY INDEX OPEN (Top 25 - old-style scoring system)
RankNameHometownOccupationPoints
1Dana DuffieldRochester, Minn.Engineer207,386
2Mike NeaseWest Chicago, Ill.Fantasy Football Writer207,160
3Brian SauberDenver, Colo.Engineer206,991
4Mike CarlsonSacramento, Calif.Fantasy Football Pro206,964
5Bradley WolfrumAlpharetta, Ga.Small Business Owner206,927
6Curt GoldgrabeBoise, IdahoExecutive Director206,880
7Michael LivengoodWard, Ark.Newspaper designer206,579
8Scott LilesRussellville, Ark.Gentleman Adventurer206,562
9S. LindMonmouth Junction, N.J.Doctor206,522
10Steve MoyerAlameda, Calif.Investment Realtor206,326
11Aaron SucovMonmouth Junction, N.J.Student206,326
12Jeff RicheyFlower Mound, TexasPhone technician206,306
13John D. SmithMount Laurel, N.J.Warehouse Manager206,231
14Mike ClayFleetwood, Pa.Fantasy Football Writer206,196
15Stephen MckenzieRed Wing, Minn.Books Are Fun Sales Rep206,184
16Tom DeskovitzSouth Lyon, Mich.Advertising Executive206,159
17Chad EisenhowerReading, Pa.Sales206,042
18Brant HollenbeckLansing, Mich.Sales205,954
19John O'KaneFlemington, N.J.Catholic Priest205,946
20Tom OverbergerBedminster, Pa.Guidance Counselor205,890
21Mike BallietMilton, Pa.Laborer205,888
22Victor KitzesMaple Valley, Wash.Sales205,862
23Mark FaberColumbus, OhioBarter205,794
24Jim DilorenzoGrayslake, Ill.Production Planner205,779
25Eric StancliffMount Airy, Md.Police Officer205,758

Here are the official results for all 209 entries, in alphabetical order. For this one, it’s the 30-11 scoring scale. For each contestent, I’m showing his total points, and his rank (out of 209) at each position.

FANTASY INDEX OPEN (alphabetical)
NameQBRBWRTEPKSTOverallRk
Aaron Sucov13271111057188391,6507
Adam Holtz24194127118190126380,450158
Adam Locke751045013713111388,36540
Adam Renzoni1911111817215924378,266176
Adam Sheets1553876315616387,64553
Adam Thygeson47811952015899383,507124
Alan Kaster2313817815388201383,067130
Alessandro Miglio1203110036194155383,712121
Andy Gough1424117716749159382,494142
Andy Richardson119651401358250384,88090
Austin Lee38217437197178386,63166
Bill Mason491971392077727378,284175
Bill Rehor3512412213216248385,44183
Bob Adelman601841691341638384,128112
Bob Buchner1452071561915370374,409197
Bob Stone178167167114142182376,870189
Bob Tecca7811531818754387,99045
Brack Varnon8313437683357388,28243
Brad Freeman7218616061468383,818118
Brad Henderson17412530483622386,11474
Bradley Wolfrum177158356934389,41125
Brant Hollenbeck221743143207389,64322
Brent Miles271178581139135386,92663
Brett Sanborn57764674126176386,79664
Brian Carlson1021931891615244378,464172
Brian George112136148168171136379,883162
Brian Laskiewicz1531501311211168384,469103
Brian Sauber1431895145166389,17527
Brian Staines894914117116141384,300108
Bryan Sweet160266515861193384,59398
Chad Eisenhower1109166155882388,51738
Chris Blacksmith1258246020864384,397106
Chris Durham182958910691120381,981147
Chris Lingen8012116434137129383,368126
Chris Whitney197198992838208374,837196
Chris Winder179676116311556383,153129
Clifford Quinn1691061011268567382,976134
Cory Bonini74726350131123387,15258
Craig Robinson20782150767574373,366199
Curt Goldgrabe32288012168106390,10717
Dan Frye20118028908394378,894170
Dan Schneier183708614193138381,219152
Dana Duffield5410114073114393,0423
Daniel Bowman3318926224320388,63734
Darrell Duke1501391091766199382,719140
Dave Bernhard1988441157177113379,036168
Dave Cohen1481472330178127382,898137
Dave Iampieri2118120019319695377,445184
Dave Read876213816412284384,570101
David Aikenhead101143157185204146377,013188
David Digregorio9245208104727381,888149
David J Thornton2082081353131186342,759208
Dean Tuffie3766115337102390,67012
Dennis Thomas1701336717311197381,945148
Derek Mathis551435216972391,6478
Dish Adams13513572392015382,904136
Don Pavelka16420313120618685371,927203
Doug Pawlak4641441928173390,75110
Ed O'Hair1381401049310191383,793119
Ed Weiss364814515135121387,90849
Eddie Tietchen1581771711179635379,812165
Edward Winklosky96116171212788387,97346
Eric Buchholz17156201902055385,73979
Eric Gustitus71225170191128388,54037
Eric Hotz151851252670187383,730120
Eric Scolnick13116994152443385,19786
Eric Stancliff9148665854177389,24626
Gary Allen1752041743318325374,160198
Gary Stehly15457149154207190376,026191
Geoff Maleman69153161953023385,82377
Gilberto Baca1084218715010891383,287127
Greg Heminway132341474116362384,468104
Hank Dabruzzi7719212910812112383,062132
Harriett Hunt206201207156199133357,216207
Henry Goers1684618018479124380,542156
Henry Karsen2021991841189149370,108205
Ian Allan11110211918613079382,454144
Isaac Mcnally106331822038148383,511123
Jake Boegel1992024519218217372,504201
James Sutter1861011464714721381,053153
James Wimmers121224811914129387,46656
Jamie Alberts1160711412636391,9386
Jason Collington6519082792001382,480143
Jason Howe81200110181711384,240109
Jason Pilon192291618380164382,736139
Jason Spann147538478120140384,589100
Jeff Fell7917020438180125377,346185
Jeff Fossett12916617516940203378,938169
Jeff Richey10335134244139389,04728
Jeff Slawson137107185195132156377,812181
Jeffery Lebeouf28616473165163387,91947
Jeremy Schwartz829719142173151384,60297
Jim Costello116131582001194385,22785
Jim Dilorenzo6794772997175386,55467
Jim Kangas196991121785671380,045160
Jim Nienaber1851649716010060379,852164
Joe Vlcek151879019817492382,289145
John D. Smith4054791013243390,8099
John Duggins3415915911094154384,006115
John Isett1619210516618786380,383159
John Marino1411552052722194378,217177
John Moore73112113129143204382,575141
John O'Kane9088611311710388,98030
John Richmond152149173125202144375,973192
John Roberts156103761749069382,945135
John Ruppe1731831701966513378,147179
Jon Elliott Hansen1949851139198153377,795182
Jonathan Mora98361307767171386,38470
Joseph Michelangelo4340887576108389,75820
Juan Novo5214136536174390,17716
Justin Morris100176190149188119377,230187
Keenan Raverty101588191129147387,24557
Keith Mason134145120977160384,018114
Keith Mcgrail8861519263100388,59336
Ken Yuen115173310517689386,94661
Kent Bailey13059201123134158379,145167
Kevin Cuozzo3185109157200388,17744
Kevin Hall27515216215497387,63554
Kevin Smith39163197432139384,444105
Kevin Weakland2031443814310547378,024180
Kirk Kennedy869059759183387,90350
Lou Sanicola2001109661203150375,369194
Louis Dale Gander16210587853958384,99687
Manny De Jesus291731761306432384,93989
Marc Price122441544164170386,19872
Mark Burns598658987476388,59735
Mark Faber14074545612198385,58481
Mark Kundrotas114154126899141384,64396
Mark Stoecker12824424215040387,78952
Matt Becker4250102109125101387,84951
Matt Hayes18852123255145384,84892
Matt Kons19312012114720615375,838193
Michael Cabaza10913121133138116384,64695
Michael Crow1241569346192103381,471151
Michael Kolton105122163124181132380,476157
Michael Livengood2623681001919393,3792
Michael Mcaninch1571141416124198384,162111
Michael Mccleary91251991028137384,358107
Michael Mcilraith701281921792363382,754138
Michael Murillo9917516220589172378,179178
Michael O'Brien11877814018412386,99160
Michael Phillips163123271766896383,476125
Michael Sarmento418311684205104383,204128
Michael Stanco851220213610783383,667122
Miguel Tames13920981311792386,41069
Mike Balliet1494114234730389,84819
Mike Carlson5019365999179389,65221
Mike Clay2511847211390390,33815
Mike Craig8432196945065385,31184
Mike Green204161296711631378,295174
Mike Mcilraith971009269133145384,59199
Mike Nease11716345725152389,52323
Mike Todd190165351875578380,695155
Mike Wells166188419713633380,768154
Mitch Wurst61931838018107385,79478
Moishe Steigmann94392218810928387,53455
Nathan Kline12196732024277384,023113
Nathan Priest954310610792184385,61680
Nathan Roberts10717819312014893378,410173
Paul Hazen51791814414080387,91548
Paul Kuchar20589562103205388,31541
Peter Steinke761327021149180384,81993
Rey Diaz159776217214137384,78194
Rich Hodges19515116817784202375,081195
Richard Brisacher17218269175175167377,261186
Richard Jackson16152558153130388,45939
Richard Loppnow123301084598181385,54082
Richard Meadors20516819411178110370,467204
Rick Calabro16716211711135109381,764150
Rob Dammers11319520620415196372,285202
Rob Reiber6291526421165388,70532
Robert Cowart551275782106142386,42868
Rocky Petrella931718311616753383,062133
Ronald John Robuck18920619820819581363,494206
Russell Ditnes6420515416517073376,111190
Rustin Paul18060447060195384,181110
Rusty Stephens667115512793134384,94288
S. Lind7965614662105390,65913
Sam Hendricks56516096128185386,93862
Scott Anderson171291882011446383,987116
Scott Brady68111288634143389,41824
Scott Kopischke45474914511459388,95231
Scott Liles446855511266390,72511
Scott Martin184191186148172115373,224200
Scott Sachs16578203885157379,993161
Sebastian Falsone311301531381189386,22071
Shane Scott5355179322418388,64633
Shiaw Chi144126172586161382,079146
Stephen Coleman1877339994614385,89576
Stephen Fisse588940155104122386,73965
Stephen Mckenzie4813724912746390,41314
Steve Hoyt13614175654206383,826117
Steve Moyer631131213142392,8174
Steve Tortora193719118029168386,18773
Thomas Oliver1811461658316061378,806171
Tim Lloyd12717213266152192379,880163
Tim Wandling13310832879526386,10475
Todd Voorhees1461142122123118387,10259
Tom Deskovitz188717148131393,9161
Tom Overberger4634311510151392,7085
Tommy Libretti209209209209209209249,592209
Tony Zeller88012412811087389,02629
Travis Billman1110991194155189384,87591
Travis Gray3014210318216652384,524102
Treavor Phipps176179107189145117377,742183
Troy Tretola10415711819918575379,583166
Ty Tietjen12611913310371162383,063131
Victor Kitzes66313754151169388,29842
Zach Leavitt14695315910249390,01218

--Ian Allan

Fantasy Index