Seattle and New England in a Super Bowl rematch. How’s that sound? I have gone through the 256 regular-season games, assigning win probabilities to each, and to me, it looks like the Seahawks and Patriots have the best chance of securing home-field advantage.
If my calculations are correct, the standings at the end of the year should look something like this …
2016 NFL STANDINGS | ||
---|---|---|
Team | Win | Loss |
Seattle | 11.82 | 4.18 |
New England | 11.73 | 4.27 |
Carolina | 11.65 | 4.35 |
Arizona | 11.06 | 4.94 |
Green Bay | 10.48 | 5.52 |
Washington | 9.74 | 6.26 |
Houston | 9.69 | 6.31 |
Pittsburgh | 9.60 | 6.40 |
Cincinnati | 9.41 | 6.59 |
Dallas | 9.02 | 6.98 |
Minnesota | 8.88 | 7.12 |
Baltimore | 8.66 | 7.34 |
Kansas City | 8.37 | 7.63 |
NY Giants | 8.37 | 7.63 |
Denver | 8.35 | 7.66 |
San Diego | 8.21 | 7.79 |
Oakland | 8.12 | 7.88 |
Jacksonville | 7.89 | 8.11 |
Tennessee | 7.68 | 8.32 |
NY Jets | 7.65 | 8.35 |
Detroit | 7.04 | 8.96 |
Tampa Bay | 6.98 | 9.02 |
Indianapolis | 6.93 | 9.07 |
Buffalo | 6.90 | 9.10 |
Atlanta | 6.40 | 9.60 |
Miami | 6.28 | 9.72 |
New Orleans | 5.96 | 10.04 |
Chicago | 5.75 | 10.25 |
Los Angeles | 5.70 | 10.31 |
Philadelphia | 4.27 | 11.73 |
San Francisco | 3.72 | 12.28 |
Cleveland | 3.70 | 12.30 |
This is built from my usual process of forecasting each of the 256 regular-season games. For each, you give each team some portion of a win and some portion of a loss. San Francisco will play at Carolina, Arizona and Seattle. The 49ers grade down at almost zero for each of those games, with the Panthers, Cardinals and Seahawks collecting almost full wins.
When the matchups are closer, the win gets divvied up. If an 8-8 type team is playing at another 8-8 opponent, I would tend to give the home field a 54 percent chance of winning. (In the NFL, home teams historically have won 54 percent of the time, so that’s apparently about the value of home-field advantage.)
This is my stab at it. I have the Seahawks, Panthers, Patriots and Texans getting first-round byes. Other division winners include the Packers, Washington, Steelers and Kansas City. Wild cards would be Arizona, Dallas, Cincinnati and Baltimore.
The AFC West projects to be the closest division, with all four teams finishing with between 8.12 and 8.37 wins.
The two teams originally from the All America Football Conference, Cleveland and San Francisco, project to be picking first in next spring’s draft.
As usual with this kind of thing, let me know where you think I’m off.
GAME-BY-GAME PROJECTIONS | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Wk | Team | Prob | Opponent | Prob |
1 | Miami | 9% | at Seattle | 91% |
1 | Chicago | 17% | at Houston | 83% |
1 | Buffalo | 38% | at Baltimore | 62% |
1 | Pittsburgh | 41% | at Washington | 59% |
1 | New England | 41% | at Arizona | 59% |
1 | San Diego | 43% | at Kansas City | 57% |
1 | Cleveland | 43% | at Philadelphia | 57% |
1 | NY Giants | 44% | at Dallas | 56% |
1 | Detroit | 45% | at Indianapolis | 55% |
1 | Carolina | 47% | at Denver | 53% |
1 | Tampa Bay | 48% | at Atlanta | 52% |
1 | Minnesota | 50% | at Tennessee | 50% |
1 | Cincinnati | 52% | at NY Jets | 48% |
1 | Green Bay | 53% | at Jacksonville | 47% |
1 | Los Angeles | 55% | at San Francisco | 45% |
1 | Oakland | 56% | at New Orleans | 44% |
2 | San Francisco | 1% | at Carolina | 99% |
2 | Miami | 20% | at New England | 80% |
2 | Tampa Bay | 24% | at Arizona | 76% |
2 | Indianapolis | 35% | at Denver | 65% |
2 | New Orleans | 36% | at NY Giants | 64% |
2 | Atlanta | 36% | at Oakland | 64% |
2 | Philadelphia | 39% | at Chicago | 61% |
2 | Dallas | 40% | at Washington | 60% |
2 | Kansas City | 41% | at Houston | 59% |
2 | Jacksonville | 44% | at San Diego | 56% |
2 | Tennessee | 47% | at Detroit | 53% |
2 | Cincinnati | 48% | at Pittsburgh | 52% |
2 | NY Jets | 51% | at Buffalo | 49% |
2 | Green Bay | 54% | at Minnesota | 46% |
2 | Baltimore | 74% | at Cleveland | 26% |
2 | Seattle | 80% | at Los Angeles | 20% |
3 | San Francisco | 1% | at Seattle | 99% |
3 | Detroit | 22% | at Green Bay | 78% |
3 | Minnesota | 30% | at Carolina | 70% |
3 | Chicago | 30% | at Dallas | 70% |
3 | Cleveland | 32% | at Miami | 69% |
3 | Los Angeles | 40% | at Tampa Bay | 60% |
3 | NY Jets | 41% | at Kansas City | 59% |
3 | Denver | 42% | at Cincinnati | 58% |
3 | Houston | 44% | at New England | 56% |
3 | Baltimore | 47% | at Jacksonville | 53% |
3 | Atlanta | 47% | at New Orleans | 53% |
3 | Oakland | 48% | at Tennessee | 52% |
3 | San Diego | 50% | at Indianapolis | 50% |
3 | Washington | 54% | at NY Giants | 46% |
3 | Arizona | 66% | at Buffalo | 34% |
3 | Pittsburgh | 75% | at Philadelphia | 25% |
4 | Los Angeles | 10% | at Arizona | 90% |
4 | Cleveland | 10% | at Washington | 90% |
4 | Buffalo | 24% | at New England | 76% |
4 | Miami | 28% | at Cincinnati | 72% |
4 | Tennessee | 31% | at Houston | 69% |
4 | New Orleans | 32% | at San Diego | 68% |
4 | NY Giants | 38% | at Minnesota | 62% |
4 | Kansas City | 42% | at Pittsburgh | 58% |
4 | Oakland | 45% | at Baltimore | 55% |
4 | Detroit | 51% | at Chicago | 49% |
4 | Jacksonville | 53% | vs. Indianapolis | 47% |
4 | Denver | 55% | at Tampa Bay | 45% |
4 | Seattle | 68% | at NY Jets | 32% |
4 | Dallas | 75% | at San Francisco | 25% |
4 | Carolina | 76% | at Atlanta | 24% |
5 | Tampa Bay | 18% | at Carolina | 82% |
5 | NY Giants | 30% | at Green Bay | 70% |
5 | Atlanta | 32% | at Denver | 69% |
5 | Philadelphia | 33% | at Detroit | 67% |
5 | NY Jets | 38% | at Pittsburgh | 62% |
5 | Chicago | 38% | at Indianapolis | 62% |
5 | San Diego | 44% | at Oakland | 56% |
5 | Buffalo | 50% | at Los Angeles | 50% |
5 | Tennessee | 51% | at Miami | 49% |
5 | Washington | 52% | at Baltimore | 48% |
5 | Houston | 52% | at Minnesota | 48% |
5 | Cincinnati | 52% | at Dallas | 48% |
5 | Arizona | 85% | at San Francisco | 15% |
5 | New England | 96% | at Cleveland | 4% |
6 | Philadelphia | 13% | at Washington | 87% |
6 | Atlanta | 14% | at Seattle | 86% |
6 | Cleveland | 20% | at Tennessee | 80% |
6 | San Francisco | 21% | at Buffalo | 79% |
6 | NY Jets | 28% | at Arizona | 72% |
6 | Cincinnati | 28% | at New England | 72% |
6 | Indianapolis | 30% | at Houston | 70% |
6 | Dallas | 35% | at Green Bay | 65% |
6 | Los Angeles | 40% | at Detroit | 60% |
6 | Kansas City | 47% | at Oakland | 53% |
6 | Denver | 48% | at San Diego | 52% |
6 | Baltimore | 49% | at NY Giants | 51% |
6 | Jacksonville | 58% | at Chicago | 42% |
6 | Pittsburgh | 64% | at Miami | 36% |
6 | Carolina | 78% | at New Orleans | 22% |
7 | Cleveland | 13% | at Cincinnati | 87% |
7 | Chicago | 15% | at Green Bay | 85% |
7 | New Orleans | 32% | at Kansas City | 69% |
7 | Los Angeles | 36% | vs. NY Giants | 64% |
7 | Indianapolis | 46% | at Tennessee | 54% |
7 | Buffalo | 46% | at Miami | 54% |
7 | Seattle | 48% | at Arizona | 52% |
7 | Oakland | 48% | at Jacksonville | 52% |
7 | Baltimore | 50% | at NY Jets | 50% |
7 | San Diego | 52% | at Atlanta | 48% |
7 | Houston | 52% | at Denver | 48% |
7 | New England | 58% | at Pittsburgh | 42% |
7 | Washington | 59% | at Detroit | 41% |
7 | Tampa Bay | 64% | at San Francisco | 36% |
7 | Minnesota | 75% | at Philadelphia | 25% |
8 | Philadelphia | 23% | at Dallas | 77% |
8 | Detroit | 25% | at Houston | 75% |
8 | Arizona | 41% | at Carolina | 59% |
8 | San Diego | 44% | at Denver | 56% |
8 | Jacksonville | 48% | at Tennessee | 52% |
8 | Washington | 50% | vs. Cincinnati | 50% |
8 | Oakland | 53% | at Tampa Bay | 47% |
8 | Kansas City | 53% | at Indianapolis | 47% |
8 | Minnesota | 68% | at Chicago | 32% |
8 | Green Bay | 68% | at Atlanta | 32% |
8 | NY Jets | 70% | at Cleveland | 30% |
8 | New England | 78% | at Buffalo | 22% |
8 | Seattle | 80% | at New Orleans | 20% |
9 | Buffalo | 18% | at Seattle | 82% |
9 | Indianapolis | 25% | at Green Bay | 75% |
9 | Philadelphia | 28% | at NY Giants | 72% |
9 | Detroit | 32% | at Minnesota | 69% |
9 | Jacksonville | 42% | at Kansas City | 58% |
9 | Atlanta | 43% | at Tampa Bay | 57% |
9 | Tennessee | 44% | at San Diego | 56% |
9 | Denver | 47% | at Oakland | 53% |
9 | Pittsburgh | 49% | at Baltimore | 51% |
9 | NY Jets | 52% | at Miami | 48% |
9 | New Orleans | 56% | at San Francisco | 44% |
9 | Dallas | 74% | at Cleveland | 26% |
9 | Carolina | 82% | at Los Angeles | 18% |
10 | San Francisco | 2% | at Arizona | 98% |
10 | Cleveland | 18% | at Baltimore | 82% |
10 | Kansas City | 25% | at Carolina | 75% |
10 | Miami | 35% | at San Diego | 65% |
10 | Los Angeles | 36% | at NY Jets | 64% |
10 | Chicago | 37% | at Tampa Bay | 63% |
10 | Dallas | 39% | at Pittsburgh | 61% |
10 | Minnesota | 40% | at Washington | 60% |
10 | Seattle | 41% | at New England | 59% |
10 | Houston | 53% | at Jacksonville | 47% |
10 | Cincinnati | 55% | at NY Giants | 45% |
10 | Atlanta | 57% | at Philadelphia | 43% |
10 | Denver | 62% | at New Orleans | 38% |
10 | Green Bay | 64% | at Tennessee | 36% |
11 | Philadelphia | 2% | at Seattle | 98% |
11 | New Orleans | 12% | at Carolina | 88% |
11 | Buffalo | 30% | at Cincinnati | 70% |
11 | Chicago | 35% | at NY Giants | 65% |
11 | Tampa Bay | 36% | at Kansas City | 64% |
11 | Tennessee | 47% | at Indianapolis | 53% |
11 | Miami | 47% | at Los Angeles | 53% |
11 | Baltimore | 47% | at Dallas | 53% |
11 | Green Bay | 50% | at Washington | 50% |
11 | Jacksonville | 52% | at Detroit | 48% |
11 | Arizona | 52% | at Minnesota | 48% |
11 | Houston | 59% | vs. Oakland | 41% |
11 | Pittsburgh | 78% | at Cleveland | 22% |
11 | New England | 94% | at San Francisco | 6% |
12 | San Francisco | 31% | at Miami | 69% |
12 | San Diego | 34% | at Houston | 66% |
12 | Los Angeles | 46% | at New Orleans | 54% |
12 | Kansas City | 47% | at Denver | 53% |
12 | Cincinnati | 50% | at Baltimore | 50% |
12 | Washington | 52% | at Dallas | 48% |
12 | Jacksonville | 52% | at Buffalo | 48% |
12 | Tennessee | 55% | at Chicago | 45% |
12 | Minnesota | 60% | at Detroit | 40% |
12 | Pittsburgh | 62% | at Indianapolis | 38% |
12 | Carolina | 65% | at Oakland | 35% |
12 | NY Giants | 66% | at Cleveland | 34% |
12 | New England | 71% | at NY Jets | 29% |
12 | Seattle | 75% | at Tampa Bay | 25% |
12 | Arizona | 75% | at Atlanta | 25% |
12 | Green Bay | 83% | at Philadelphia | 17% |
13 | Los Angeles | 7% | at New England | 93% |
13 | Philadelphia | 12% | at Cincinnati | 88% |
13 | Miami | 32% | at Baltimore | 68% |
13 | NY Giants | 38% | at Pittsburgh | 62% |
13 | San Francisco | 40% | at Chicago | 60% |
13 | Washington | 40% | at Arizona | 60% |
13 | Tampa Bay | 40% | at San Diego | 60% |
13 | Buffalo | 41% | at Oakland | 59% |
13 | Indianapolis | 42% | at NY Jets | 58% |
13 | Dallas | 43% | at Minnesota | 57% |
13 | Houston | 46% | at Green Bay | 54% |
13 | Carolina | 48% | at Seattle | 52% |
13 | Detroit | 48% | at New Orleans | 52% |
13 | Denver | 49% | at Jacksonville | 51% |
13 | Kansas City | 56% | at Atlanta | 44% |
14 | San Diego | 20% | at Carolina | 80% |
14 | Baltimore | 23% | at New England | 77% |
14 | Chicago | 40% | at Detroit | 60% |
14 | New Orleans | 41% | at Tampa Bay | 59% |
14 | Oakland | 45% | at Kansas City | 55% |
14 | Dallas | 48% | at NY Giants | 52% |
14 | Atlanta | 48% | at Los Angeles | 52% |
14 | Seattle | 49% | at Green Bay | 51% |
14 | Minnesota | 50% | at Jacksonville | 50% |
14 | Denver | 52% | at Tennessee | 48% |
14 | Houston | 56% | at Indianapolis | 44% |
14 | Pittsburgh | 58% | at Buffalo | 42% |
14 | NY Jets | 68% | at San Francisco | 32% |
14 | Arizona | 73% | at Miami | 27% |
14 | Washington | 78% | at Philadelphia | 22% |
14 | Cincinnati | 78% | at Cleveland | 22% |
15 | New Orleans | 10% | at Arizona | 90% |
15 | Los Angeles | 15% | at Seattle | 85% |
15 | Philadelphia | 23% | at Baltimore | 77% |
15 | San Francisco | 30% | at Atlanta | 70% |
15 | Jacksonville | 32% | at Houston | 68% |
15 | Indianapolis | 33% | at Minnesota | 67% |
15 | Cleveland | 33% | at Buffalo | 67% |
15 | Tampa Bay | 35% | at Dallas | 65% |
15 | Tennessee | 38% | at Kansas City | 62% |
15 | Miami | 40% | at NY Jets | 60% |
15 | Detroit | 40% | at NY Giants | 60% |
15 | Oakland | 47% | at San Diego | 53% |
15 | Pittsburgh | 48% | at Cincinnati | 52% |
15 | Carolina | 56% | at Washington | 44% |
15 | New England | 65% | at Denver | 35% |
15 | Green Bay | 75% | at Chicago | 25% |
16 | Atlanta | 13% | at Carolina | 87% |
16 | NY Jets | 21% | at New England | 79% |
16 | San Francisco | 34% | at Los Angeles | 66% |
16 | Indianapolis | 36% | at Oakland | 64% |
16 | Detroit | 37% | at Dallas | 63% |
16 | Tennessee | 42% | at Jacksonville | 58% |
16 | Minnesota | 42% | at Green Bay | 58% |
16 | Cincinnati | 42% | at Houston | 58% |
16 | Baltimore | 42% | at Pittsburgh | 58% |
16 | Miami | 43% | at Buffalo | 57% |
16 | Arizona | 43% | at Seattle | 57% |
16 | Denver | 46% | at Kansas City | 54% |
16 | Tampa Bay | 50% | at New Orleans | 50% |
16 | NY Giants | 67% | at Philadelphia | 33% |
16 | San Diego | 73% | at Cleveland | 27% |
16 | Washington | 74% | at Chicago | 26% |
17 | Cleveland | 10% | at Pittsburgh | 90% |
17 | Chicago | 23% | at Minnesota | 77% |
17 | NY Giants | 35% | at Washington | 65% |
17 | Baltimore | 41% | at Cincinnati | 59% |
17 | Oakland | 45% | at Denver | 55% |
17 | New Orleans | 45% | at Atlanta | 55% |
17 | Buffalo | 45% | at NY Jets | 55% |
17 | Kansas City | 49% | at San Diego | 51% |
17 | Jacksonville | 50% | at Indianapolis | 50% |
17 | Houston | 59% | at Tennessee | 41% |
17 | Green Bay | 65% | at Detroit | 35% |
17 | Dallas | 68% | at Philadelphia | 32% |
17 | Carolina | 73% | at Tampa Bay | 27% |
17 | Arizona | 74% | at Los Angeles | 26% |
17 | New England | 78% | at Miami | 22% |
17 | Seattle | 91% | at San Francisco | 9% |