Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Around the NFL

Backup running backs

Anderson, Blue don't seem to be created equal

A couple of teams signed backup running backs yesterday. The Jaguars added former division opponent backup Alfred Blue away from Houston, and the Lions signed C.J. Anderson. Both are ticketed for similar roles with their new teams, probably little-used No. 2 running backs. But results may vary.

Over the last three seasons, Blue has been asked to take on a sizable role in 13 different games; that's how many times he's had double-digit carries. He's been under 3.0 yards per carry in nearly half (six) of those games, and at 3.8 or worse in three more. Not particularly effective, then, in most of his contests.

BLUE GAME LOG, 2016-2018 (10-PLUS CARRIES)
YearOppAttYdsAvgTD
2016@ DEN 11635.70
2016@ IND 16553.40
2016CIN 21733.51
2016@ TEN 11282.50
2017@ JAX 12554.60
2017PIT 161086.80
2017@ IND 18392.21
2018@ IND 13312.40
2018DAL 20462.30
2018MIA 15422.80
2018@ DEN 15392.60
2018TEN 13493.80
2018CLE 13544.20
Total1946823.52

Anderson was a starter for Denver back in 2016 and some of 2017, then a backup with the Rams late last season. He was a lot more effective in his games, averaging over 4.0 yards per carry in about two-thirds (13) of his 21 games, over 4.5 in more than half of them.

ANDERSON GAME LOG, 2016-2018 (10-PLUS CARRIES)
YearOppAttYdsAvgTD
2016CAR 20924.61
2016IND 20743.71
2016@ CIN 14372.60
2016@ TB 19492.61
2016ATL 11413.70
2016@ SD 10373.70
2016HOU 161076.71
2017LAC 20814.10
2017DAL 251184.71
2017OAK 20954.80
2017@ LAC 10444.40
2017@ KC 15785.20
2017NE 10545.40
2017CIN 13372.81
2017@ MIA 15674.50
2017NYJ 22482.20
2017@ IND 301585.30
2017@ WAS 16885.51
2017KC 18613.40
2018@ ARI 201678.41
2018SF 231325.71
Total36716654.59

For whatever reason, Anderson doesn't seem to endear himself to teams. The Broncos constantly tried to replace him with Ronnie Hillman before finally letting him go. The Panthers didn't use him much before releasing him last season, and the Rams didn't have any interest in bringing him back even after he carried the running game down the stretch, with Todd Gurley hurting.

In Jacksonville, behind the oft-hurt Leonard Fournette, Blue (if he winds up as the No. 2) looks more likely to be need to start some games. But Anderson looks more likely to be effective if called upon.

--Andy Richardson

Fantasy Index