Andrew Beck had the weirdest play of Week 3 – a 255-pound fullback returning a kickoff 85 yards for a touchdown at Jacksonville. It was strange to see a player that large run that far for a touchdown. (Nice coverage, Jaguars.)

I made a mental note of it, wanting to look into it further after putting together the preview products of the week.

Turns out there are only two other players weighing more than 240 pounds who’ve scored on kickoff returns, and both were under 50 yards (so returns, I presume, where a team was attempting an onside kick).

Casey FitzSimmons did it for the Lions in 2007. FitzSimmons was a 258-pound tight end. And guard Mal Snider scored on a 48-yard return for the Falcons in 1969. If we adjust for players being smaller at that time, Snider’s 254 pounds is relatively a lot larger than FitzSimmons’ 258 or Beck’s 255.

The search tools at pro-football-reference.com indicate that seven other players weighing from 230-240 pounds have scored on kickoff returns. That includes six running backs who were kickoff returners (Cullen Bryant did it three times) and linebacker Tyjuan Hagler scoring on a short one in 2010 (presumably on an onside kick attempt).

HEAVIEST PLAYERS TO SCORE ON KICKOFF RETURNS
YearPlayerHtWtOppResultYds
2007Casey FitzSimmons, Det.6-4258Chi.W 37-2741
2023• Andrew Beck, Hou.6-3255at Jac.W 37-1785
1969Mal Snider, Atl.6-4254Chi.W 48-3148
2004Derrick Ward, NYG5-11240at Was.L 7-3192
1964Andy Livingston, Chi.6-1236Min.L 14-4186
2010Tyjuan Hagler, Ind.6-0236Jac.W 34-2441
1974Cullen Bryant, LAR6-1234at Den.W 17-1084
1973Cullen Bryant, LAR6-1234at S.F.W 40-2093
1976Cullen Bryant, LAR6-1234St.L.L 28-3090
1992Darren Lewis, Chi.5-10230Cin.L 28-3197

Statistics compiled using search tools at Pro-Football-Reference.com

—Ian Allan