Fantasy Index

header banner img
Optimize Your Lineups Each Week With In-Season Cheat Sheets
Win here.

Around the NFL

Tyrone Tracy

Knee injury shelves Giants rookie

It’s looking like the Giants have a winner in their backup running back battle, at least for the short term. Tyrone Tracy left practice with a knee injury today, making it look like Eric Gray will open the season as their No. 2 back (behind Devin Singletary).

Tracy, who played more receiver than running back in college, had been a standout at camp, making him look like a sneaky late-round possibility. They started him in their first preseason game, and he looked just fine, carrying 5 times for 26 yards.

Would it be all that strange if Brian Daboll in October decided he liked Tracy more than Singletary?

But that No. 2 running back position got clouded on Saturday when Gray (after replacing Tracy) ripped off a 48-yard touchdown run (with the help of a nice move and some shoddy tackling). Gray’s other 3 carries netted only 4 total yards but including a 1-yard touchdown, and he caught 4 passes for 46 yards.

I left that game thinking we’d need to re-visit Tracy vs. Gray in the remaining preseason games. Both are fifth-round picks. Gray (who’s pictured) as a rookie carried 17 times for only 48 yards.

But this injury changes things. The indicates it’s just a sprain, rather than a season-ender, but unlikely that he’ll be in uniform again before September. Gray will be sucking up the reps the rest of the way, and the team is probably planning on him being that No. 2 guy.

Once Tracy gets back up to full speed, he can get back to trying to climb his way into some kind of role. But he’s not draftable right now for a 2024 league. (Dynasty league, I would still select Tracy before Gray).

Gray should be your Week 1 backup for the Giants, and that should sneak him into the last round of some drafts. Singletary gets hurt or struggles early in the season, and Gray could be something.

While Gray didn’t do much of anything as a rookie, that doesn’t worry me much. It’s not all that uncommon for backs to come on in their second seasons.

In the last 10 years, 100 running backs have put up top-30 numbers in their second season (using PPR scoring). A third (33) of those running backs are guys who didn’t put up top-60 numbers as rookies.

Those 33 second-year backs are listed below. The last two columns shows what they did during their underwhelming rookie seasons (the stats shows three numbers – rushing yards, receiving yards and touchdowns – while the final column shows where they ranked among running backs).

Last year, two second-year running backs went from afterthoughts to relevant: Kyren Williams and Jerome Ford.

SECOND-YEAR BACKS MAKING A BIG MOVE UP
YearPlayerRunRecTDPPRRookiePPR
2002Marcel Shipp, Ari.834413922nd0-0-0---
2002Deuce McAllister, N.O.1388352168th91-166-265th
2003Brian Westbrook, Phil.6133321320th193-86-081th
2003Rudi Johnson, Cin.957146921th67-34-0110th
2004Willis McGahee, Buff.11281691314thinj---
2004Chris Brown, Ten.1067147626th221-61-088th
2004Larry Johnson, K.C.5812781127th85-2-1116th
2005Willie Parker, Pitt.1202218518th186-16-0104th
2005Tatum Bell, Den.921104824th396-80-363rd
2007LenDale White, Ten.1110114718th244-60-072nd
2008LeRon McClain, Balt.9021231123rd18-55-199th
2009Rashard Mendenhall, Pitt.1108261817th58-17-0128th
2009Justin Forsett, Sea.619350528th0-0-0---
2010Arian Foster, Hou.1616604181st257-93-372nd
2010Danny Woodhead, 2TM547379625th64-87-0102nd
2012Stevan Ridley, N.E.1263511215th441-13-173rd
2012Mikel Leshoure, Det.798214918thinj---
2012Jacquizz Rodgers, Atl.362402229th205-188-260th
2014C.J. Anderson, Den.8493241011th38-0-0144th
2015Charles Sims, T.B.529561416th185-190-173rd
2016Jay Ajayi, Mia.1272151811th187-90-185th
2016Tevin Coleman, Atl.5204211120th392-14-179th
2017Alex Collins, Balt.973187619th125-84-182nd
2018Aaron Jones, G.B.728206924th448-22-463th
2018Chris Carson, Sea.1151163915th208-59-186th
2018Dalvin Cook, Min.615305430th354-90-272nd
2018James Conner, Pitt.973497136th144-0-0113th
2019Ronald Jones, T.B.724309625th44-33-195th
2020Myles Gaskin, Mia.584388525th133-51-190th
2021AJ Dillon, G.B.803313723rd242-21-283rd
2022Travis Etienne, Jac.1125316517thinj---
2023• Jerome Ford, Cle.813319916th12-0-0154th
2023• Kyren Williams, LAR1144206157th139-76-090th

—Ian Allan

Fantasy Index