Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Dynasty Leagues

Long-term QBs

Is Tua worth carrying in a dynasty format?

What now for Tua Tagovailoa? I don’t expect to see him on a field any time soon. So for those in dynasty leagues, at this point I think we’re comparing him against guys like J.J. McCarthy and Michael Penix. It’s not what they’re doing now, but what they might be doing in 2025 and beyond.

I am a McCarthy fan. I liked the brief glimpse we got of him in the preseason, and I like the situation – the pass catchers around him, and Kevin O’Connell drawing up the plays. I expect McCarthy will be a top-20 quarterback on my board heading into the 2025 season. I’m confident he’ll develop.

Similarly, Penix is going to play. (And as poorly as Kirk Cousins played in Week 1, maybe sooner rather than later – either Cousins physically breaks down, or he simply doesn’t play well enough.) If Atlanta is a sputtering, dysfunctional team in December, it would make sense to put Penix on the field for a few starts. If Cousins is playing anything like he did in Week 1, I don’t want to watch 17 weeks of that.

In a dynasty league, I would roster McCarthy or Penix before Tagovailoa. No question. With the Miami quarterback, I’m not positive he’ll play again. Maybe he decides to walk away, or maybe doctors won’t clear him. If and when he gets back on the field, the concussion issue will still be there.

Also consider that Tagovailoa’s game doesn’t translate well for fantasy purposes. He’s not much of a factor as a runner, so his good passing numbers don’t translate quite like you might expect. Last year, for example, he averaged 272 passing yards, with 29 TDs in 17 games, but was barely above average in typical fantasy leagues (14th in per-game production among quarterbacks who started at least half the season).

If we’re in a 12-team dynasty league, with each team carrying about three quarterbacks, I think that makes Tagovailoa (at best) a low-level third option. Below McCarthy and Penix, and I think below even guys like Bryce Young, Gardner Minshew and Daniel Jones.

My current dynasty rankings for quarterbacks appear below. (I turn my attention to dynasty leagues each Saturday, rotating between the four notable positions – QB, RB, WR, TE).

DYNASTY LEAGUE QUARTERBACKS
RkTmPlayerAge
1.KCPatrick Mahomes29.0
2.HOUC.J. Stroud22.9
3.BUFJosh Allen28.3
4.PHIJalen Hurts26.1
5.CINJoe Burrow27.8
6.GBJordan Love25.9
7.BALLamar Jackson27.7
8.CHI• Caleb Williams22.8
9.INDAnthony Richardson22.3
10.JACTrevor Lawrence24.9
11.DETJared Goff29.9
12.DALDak Prescott31.1
13.SFBrock Purdy24.7
14.WAS• Jayden Daniels23.7
15.LACJustin Herbert26.5
16.ARIKyler Murray27.1
17.TBBaker Mayfield29.4
18.DEN• Bo Nix24.6
19.LARMatthew Stafford36.6
20.MIN• J.J. McCarthy21.6
21.ATL• Michael Penix24.4
22.NE• Drake Maye22.0
23.MINSam Darnold27.3
24.NODerek Carr33.5
25.SEAGeno Smith33.9
26.ATLKirk Cousins36.1
27.CLEDeshaun Watson29.0
28.NYJAaron Rodgers40.8
29.CARBryce Young23.1
30.LVGardner Minshew29.3
31.NYGDaniel Jones27.3
32.PITJustin Fields25.5
33.TENWill Levis25.2
34.MIATua Tagovailoa26.5
35.PITRussell Wilson35.8
36.NEJacoby Brissett31.8
37.MIASkylar Thompson27.3
38.SEASam Howell24.0
39.CINJake Browning28.4
40.CLEJameis Winston30.7

—Ian Allan

Fantasy Index