Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Fantasy News

Repeat kickers -- Costello system

Even in distance format, there's fluctuation with kickers

What happens if a league richly rewards kickers who can hit long field goals? Then does it make sense to select one in the earlier rounds?

James Costello posed a question on the post from earlier today. He asked if kickers become much more valuable when they're given big bonuses for hitting long field goals. Then does it make sense to go after a guy like Sebastian Janikowski, Blair Walsh or Greg Zuerlein.

At best, maybe. The difference doesn't seem to be much.

In Costello's league, kicker points are standard, expect it's 5 points for field goals from 40-plus yards and 10 points for anything from 50-plus. That can make a kicker a whopper. Using that system, the two highest scoring kickers ever (I think) have come from the last two years. David Akers went for 227 two years ago, and Blair Walsh (helped along by 10 field goals from 50-plus) finished last season with 225.

But note that nobody would have selected either of those guys in the top 10 in those years.

There's still fluctuation, and it's still hard to select a guy with confidence he'll be a top-5 scorer at his position.

Look at this chart. It shows the team totals for the last three years. I've put in bold the eight teams that finished in the top 8 in 2011 -- the top 25 percent. Note that only one of those teams again finished in the top 8 last year, and it was one with a different kicker (Houston, which had Neil Rackers in 2011 and switched to Shayne Graham, who's got one of the weaker legs around).

Costello's in an auction leg. The trends suggest he should pay a little more than the minimum for a kicker, but that he shouldn't feel the need to break the bank.

KICKER POINTS -- COSTELLO SYSTEM
'12'11'10
Minnesota22513085
Atlanta191150151
Tampa Bay189141124
New England185168134
Houston180171155
Detroit180165163
Baltimore180155131
Cleveland177155103
Oakland170198186
NY Giants166113124
Cincinnati165160120
Denver164114130
Indianapolis161123147
San Francisco159227121
Dallas159169158
St. Louis15897160
Washington157162122
Chicago151175139
Pittsburgh149124155
Green Bay145160142
San Diego144174154
New Orleans136171144
Seattle135137123
Kansas City135127121
Arizona130107131
Miami128167165
Philadelphia128133168
Tennessee127181140
NY Jets124132147
Jacksonville122142139
Buffalo12113497
Carolina106126135

--Ian Allan

Fantasy Index