Fantasy Index

Factoid

LeSean McCoy

Eagles runner the top player on Ian Allan's board

What direction should one go at the top of the first round? I have completed the process of carefully looking at each team and each player; now I’m comparing those projections and putting together at rankings.

At the running back position, there are four guys who project to be pretty similar at the top. Jamaal Charles, Adrian Peterson, LeSean McCoy and Matt Forte. Straight off the numbers, these guys are really close, so then it becomes a question of which guy you really like.

For me, Charles doesn’t quite fit because they’ll spell him a little more this year, and their offensive line isn’t as good, having lost two starters. He’s going down at least a little in value.

Matt Forte doesn’t seem like a No. 1 guy. He might not be talented enough.

Both Forte and Adrian Peterson are also 29 years old. I’m not saying 29 year olds can’t play. It’s my belief that guys can play when they’re 30, and it’s really when guys get to 31 that we need to start being careful.

That said, when you’re looking to go big game hunting – when you want a monster season – your odds go down with a guy who is 29. When you look at the great backs in NFL history, then look at where they played their best seasons, you will seldom see a guy who’s 29. The peak years, where somebody really slams it out of the park, tends to come when a guy is 24-27 years old.

On those grounds, I think Forte and Peterson are good first-round picks – worthy selections who should go in the first half of round one – but they’re unlikely to put up the jaw-dropping seasons that you hope for from the first player chosen.

Here’s a listing of the top 30 running backs of the last 30 years. This is using the scoring system of 6 points for touchdowns and 1 point for every 10 yards. Only two of these guys were 29 years old on opening day. None were older.

McCoy will be 26 on opening day. He’s still in that window where it looks more likely he might put up an awesome season. Not much difference between these four backs, but I’m playing the age this year and going with McCoy as the top guy on my board.

TOP RUNNING BACKS OF THE LAST 30 YEARS
AvgYearPlayerRunRecTD
272006LaDainian Tomlinson1,81550831
272000Marshall Faulk1,35983026
292003Priest Holmes1,42069027
282002Priest Holmes1,61567224
261995Emmitt Smith1,77337525
282005Shaun Alexander1,8807828
251998Terrell Davis2,00821723
232009Chris Johnson2,00650316
262003Ahman Green1,88336720
242003LaDainian Tomlinson1,64572517
282001Marshall Faulk1,38276521
222000Edgerrin James1,70959418
252005Larry Johnson1,75034321
262006Larry Johnson1,78941019
242010Arian Foster1,61660418
232006Steven Jackson1,52880616
252002Ricky Williams1,85336317
291997Barry Sanders2,05330514
231992Emmitt Smith1,71333519
261999Marshall Faulk1,3811,04812
211999Edgerrin James1,55358617
251985Marcus Allen1,75955514
262005LaDainian Tomlinson1,46237020
251994Emmitt Smith1,48434122
251998Jamal Anderson1,84631916
262013Jamaal Charles1,28769319
272012Adrian Peterson2,09721713
242003Jamal Lewis2,06620514
231984Eric Dickerson2,10513914
232002LaDainian Tomlinson1,68348915

—Ian Allan

Fantasy Index