Fantasy Index

Andy Richardson

A Day of Football

Another year, another fantastic Super Bowl

If you're like me, you grew up in a time when the Super Bowl generally stunk. When it was considered a good game if the AFC lost by less than 10 points, and when people said they watched the game for the commercials without a hint of irony. Why else would you watch the Super Blowout?

Those days are gone. Year after year, we're getting great Super Bowl games. All eight of the New England Patriots' appearances in the big game this secondary have been fantastic, with each one arguably topping the previous one. People talk about the salary cap producing parity, but I don't really think that's it. More likely it's free agency, where every team that makes smart, shrewd moves in the offseason can be a contender. You also hear how the Patriots Dynasty is more impressive because it happened in the salary cap era. But I think they've benefited from a free agency time that past champions didn't have.

In any case, I think the reason these Super Bowls have all been so good (and in many cases, shootouts) is the grueling nature of the NFL season. By the time teams make it to the Super Bowl, offenses have the clear advantage over tired, beat-up defenses. There was one punt in last night's Super Bowl; virtually no defensive stops. Just open receivers running downfield time and time again.

Random thoughts:

A lot of the other "best" games haven't been that great throughout. Remember when everyone talked about how awesome Titans-Rams was? That thing was 16-0 for a good portion of the game. It had a fantastic finish, but wasn't actually that great for a lot of it. The same was true for Falcons-Patriots a year ago. Wasn't that great at 28-3. This was a back-and-forth masterpiece of entertainment.

The Foles TD reception might be my favorite Super Bowl play ever. Not only was it a trick play, but it was a trick play on fourth and goal from the 1-yard line when probably half the people watching were thinking "Kick the field goal." And it came shortly after the Patriots tried a trick play pass to their quarterback that clonked humorously off his fingertips. And it was for a touchdown, the first TD reception by a quarterback in Super Bowl history. Surprising! And totally awesome. I just sat there clapping at an honestly surprising and beautiful play. Brilliant enough to make me forget that so many of Philadelphia's other goal-line plays were godawful, like several failed two-point conversions (including one at 15-3 that they never should have attempted -- kick the extra point, guys).

All the evidence anyone needed that the what is a catch rule is hopelessly broken is that no one knew what the ruling would be on either of the Eagles' last two touchdowns. Not the players, not the fans watching, not the announcers. Collinsworth in the space of five minutes went from thinking the Ertz touchdown would stand, to be reversed, to stand. I wanted both to stand and thought both would be reversed, and the simple truth is that different officiating crews would have probably made different rulings on each one. Sure looked like they gave Clement his first foot down before he'd controlled the ball, so he should have got that last toe in for it to be a catch. On the Ertz play, I'm not even certain the ball touched the ground even if they hadn't determined he'd become a runner. Regardless, you'd say it's crazy that those controversial replay issues would crop up were it not for the fact that they've been happening week after week all season long. But hey, at least the storyline of the refs being paid off by Bob Kraft can go away for a little while.

Nice game for LeGarrette Blount. The notion of the revenge game -- a player having a big game against the team that kicked him to the curb -- gains another chapter. I've had a fondness for Blount ever since his rookie season in Tampa Bay (after being released by the Titans), when he had a couple of cool hurdling touchdowns and was a nice fantasy find. Things went south for him there, and I was never terribly impressed by him in New England. And he wasn't great in Philadelphia, either, pushed aside and eventually surpassed by Jay Ajayi. But he had a big game yesterday, a big part of why the Eagles were able to control the game with their offense. Also an impressive game for Alshon Jeffery, who dominated early, and Nelson Agholor, who was great late.

The Patriots are human, OK? In all the media and fan gushing about the Patriots, I've long tried to stamp down enthusiasm. They're great: the greatest NFL team for the longest period of time most of us have ever lived through. Their sustained success in the Super Bowl era will never be duplicated. What I've argued against is the hyperbole. Twitter talk about the Patriots playing chess while all the other NFL teams are playing checkers. Blather about how if the Patriots have two weeks to prepare they're invincible, or how perfect Brady is and how brilliant Belichick is. They're great. But they lose playoff games on the road (four of their last five), they lose (or narrowly win) Super Bowls, they make mistakes in judgment (Malcolm Butler wouldn't have been better than what they put out there at cornerback yesterday? Any why did they trade away Chandler Jones?). They're not perfect. Give them more credit than I do, that's fine. But understand that there are other good, smart, and talented NFL teams too. They just haven't done it over quite as long a period as Belichick and Brady have.

Hooray for Nick Foles. It might be fair to say the last remaining feather in Chip Kelly's cap was that he made a star out of Nick Foles. Turns out that Foles is just really pretty good. Some talk last night about whether the Eagles should trade Foles this offseason, since his value will never be higher. I think I'm in the distinct minority on this, but I think the Eagles should keep him, even knowing that he's a free agent after next season. Carson Wentz tore his ACL and LCL in December. Yes he's just a quarterback rather than a running back, but it's fair to worry he won't be fully healthy at the start of the next season. They might need Foles in 2018 far more than whatever pick (second round, perhaps) they could trade him for.

What an insane last play. Since we've seen some miracle catches in recent years in the Super Bowl, would anyone have actually been surprised if the Patriots had completed that Hail Mary at the end of the game? It was damn close, and some Eagle actually committed the grievous error of tipping the ball up into the air a little. Very close to seeing the Patriots try for a two-point conversion to end the Super Bowl or force overtime -- how crazy would that have been? Only slightly crazier than what we got, I guess.

And that's a wrap. A great game that capped a wild season, and given the number of major injuries that characterized 2017, it's fitting that the Super Bowl should be won by a backup quarterback. Sort of like a former sixth-round pick did some years ago. Congrats to the Eagles. That's one to remember.

28 Reader Comments:

Roy Sherman

Columbia, TN
2018-02-05T15:50:46Z
I for one thought both of those Eagles TDs would be reversed considering their opponent was the Patriots, but I'm glad to see that neither of them were. I think both of them were legitimate TDs. Ball movement in a player's arms doesn't always mean he's bobbling it.

Dave (MOJO) Smith

Avon Park, FL
2018-02-05T15:55:40Z
"Sure looked like they gave Clement his first foot down before he'd controlled the ball" I think the NFL is aware that everyone hates the way they are interpreting the rule now and they bent over backwards to give him the TD.

Dave (MOJO) Smith

Avon Park, FL
2018-02-05T15:57:56Z
Side issue: I don't like Michaels and Collinsworth. They dummy down too much for me and it's hard or at least it's just not fun to listen to them. What's wrong with Troy Aikman and Joe Buck or some of the others who do a great job?

ANDY RICHARDSON

Port Chester, NY
2018-02-05T16:06:44Z
Thing about the TDs is nobody would've been surprised if they were overturned. And no doubt different officiating crews would have made different rulings. Can you consider that replay was introduced to reduce human error on critical calls, and we now have a major gray area in how humans can interpret replay evidence, the system is clearly broken.

PHIL KEIL

Pottsville, PA
2018-02-05T16:09:11Z
Dave, NBC had the broadcast rights to last night's game so you get their broadcasters. If Fox had the game you would have had Aikman and Buck.

BEN HOGEVOLL

Siletz, OR
2018-02-05T16:09:56Z
I wont say I told you so but not many on this sight thought Phil had a chance.I even received a insult when I called the AFC east the milk toast league from Mr. Varnon from Texas.. I wonder if he is eating some crow this morning.I did put my money where my mouth is and didn't even take the points.

PHIL KEIL

Pottsville, PA
2018-02-05T16:17:15Z
Although I am a Seahawks fan, I am happy for the Eagles. A lot of great story lines and people to be happy for. Unfortunately, I did not get to watch the game as I was plowing snow 'til 1:30 in the morning. It sure sounds like it was a hell of a good game, though. I would have loved to listen to Merrill Reese call that game. He sure deserves to call an Eagles' S.B. victory.

Ian Allan

Seattle, WA
2018-02-05T16:55:58Z
Collinsworth gets the hype award. Made some comment about Jay Ajayi running stretch plays better than any running back in the entire league. That's setting the bar pretty high. Todd Gurley? Ezekiel Elliott? LeVeon Bell?

Ian Allan

Seattle, WA
2018-02-05T16:58:45Z
A lot of Patriot haters out there, but you must concede they tend to deliver entertaining Super Bowls. Belichick-Brady have been in eight Super Bowls, and every one of those games has been decided in the final minute.

PETE DEBIASE

Havertown, PA
2018-02-05T17:23:35Z
Phil:
There's a link to the Reese call on philly.com website. Enjoy!

PHIL KEIL

Pottsville, PA
2018-02-05T17:27:18Z
Thanks, Pete!

ANDY RICHARDSON

Port Chester, NY
2018-02-05T17:31:51Z
Fun background on the Foles TD reception play: they apparently got the idea from the Bears using it against the Vikings in 2016 (Meredith to Barkley). And the Patriots also used a similar play in 2015...against the Eagles.

Rocky Petrella

Philadelphia, PA
2018-02-05T18:14:35Z
I'm a big time Eagles fan and have posted on here various times over the last two weeks saying people were not giving them enough credit, especially Foles, so this is particularly sweet. Outside of the mediocrity of playing under Jeff Fisher, Foles has done nothing but win and put up pretty good numbers. I selfishly hope they do hold onto him but he probably deserves a chance to start somewhere. You can't tell me he's not one of the 32 best qbs in the league. Also anyone who's watched the Eagles all year would've been surprised if Pederson HAD kicked the FG on that 4th and 1. He's been doing this all year. Going for it and being aggressive. I said earlier in the week I couldn't wait to see what Doug came up with with two weeks to prepare and he did not disappoint. I think people were sleeping on how good of a coach he's become. And he out coached the great Bill Belichek in the Super Bowl. It's a joke he only got one vote in the Coach of the Year voting. Finally this could be just the beginning. They have 20 of 22 starters under contract (plus Foles) and will add the Wentz, the likely MVP before his injury, their best linebacker and future HOFer Jason Peters to this team. It's a good time to be an Eagles fan. Finally.

Drew Paterson

Ferndale, WA
2018-02-05T18:25:08Z
Lots of people in Ferndale happy that hometown-boy Doug Pederson and the Eagles were able to win the Lombardi trophy. As a Michigan alum, I'm grateful that Al Michaels pointed out the connection both time Brandon Graham made a play on Brady. Liked Pink's national anthem, more impressive since she was apparently recovering from the flu, not so wild about the half-time show although that kid in the stands got a lot of exposure and selfies with Timberlake.

ANDY RICHARDSON

Port Chester, NY
2018-02-05T18:26:12Z
I think the best for all involved is for the Eagles to keep Foles for one more year. Philly needs him back with Wentz only eight months removed from knee surgery at the start of next season. The value of a capable backup quarterback has never been clearer; would be foolish for the Eagles to downplay that. And as for Foles, I'd think waiting a year as a backup for the Super Bowl champs -- very possibly needing to start early on -- would be a minor inconvenience on the way to being a free agent in 2019, and having complete control over where he signs. I realize he gets paid sooner if traded, but he might be looking at the Browns or Jets as his best options.

Craig Larimer

Portland, OR
2018-02-05T19:34:44Z
Fly Eagles Fly! I'm a Raiders fan, but I was definitely happy to see the Eagles win and the Patriots lose. Congrats to Rocky and other Eagles fans. This has to be such an exciting time to be an Eagles fan in Pennsylvania.

I loved Pederson's moxie in those 4th downs. The one in the 4th quarter where the ball went to Ertz was amazing. If that is incomplete, I think the game is over and it's a Pats win.

PETE DEBIASE

Havertown, PA
2018-02-05T20:29:14Z
I'm with you, Rocky. I'm old enough to have sat in the stands at Franklin Field with the dummy of Kuharich hanging in effigy and the fans chanting Joe Must Go, so this is about as sweet as it gets. Couldn't have happened to a nicer group of guys and arguably the best coaching staff this franchise has ever had.

Joseph Varnon

Houston, TX
2018-02-05T21:40:02Z
it's Monday and there is no crow available because the word is still milquetoast

BEN HOGEVOLL

Siletz, OR
2018-02-06T00:35:42Z
If you want to get technical Milktoast is a eggcorn of milquetoast.Everyone knows what they mean.Bottom line I hate the patriots and they lost and I knew they would lose.They have and may always dominate the AFC milk toast,or milquetoast league but they wont win any more super bowls by the skin of their teeth with Brady and Belichek ever again.Good Riddance!

Joseph Varnon

Houston, TX
2018-02-06T00:56:57Z
I like them but did not know they had a name - eggcorn - thank you sir

BEN HOGEVOLL

Siletz, OR
2018-02-06T07:10:54Z
your welcome

Bruce Sadler

Lakeland, FL
2018-02-06T16:22:57Z
I was watching the NFL network they said that Pederson last game he started for the Eagles it was against the pats and he beat them .I also liked how Foles gave a lot of credit to Doug P for his roll as the back up called Doug a stud and he helped him .
But the pass play to Foles was that not illegal procedure on the Eagles .

Rocky Petrella

Philadelphia, PA
2018-02-06T20:06:18Z
Bruce, I didn't notice but everyone is saying it was illegal because they only had 6 men on line of scrimmage. I also read though that Alshon asked the line judge if he was lined up ok and was told yes. Even if they were lined up wrong I don't think it had a any effect on the success of the play. They didn't all leave Nick Foles uncovered because one of the WRs happened to not be right on the line of scrimmage.

Richard Spinella

North Providence, RI
2018-02-06T23:08:53Z
If Butler Plays, the Pats Win!!!!!! Belichick made a very very poor decision not to play BUTLER

Richard Spinella

North Providence, RI
2018-02-06T23:16:27Z
If I had told you before the Game That Brady would Throw for over 500 yards, he would only get sacked once at the end of the game, he would not throw an interception. the Patriots would never punt, and they would also rush for over 100 yards. you would have told me NO F...ing way with that great Phillys defense. but thats what happened and they still lost because of a total collapse on defense

Rocky Petrella

Philadelphia, PA
2018-02-06T23:54:46Z
They lost because the Eagles were the better team with the better coaching staff. Butler who's been only ok even by most Pats fans assessments wouldn't have changed that.

Rocky Petrella

Philadelphia, PA
2018-02-06T23:58:32Z
For the record I'm not say Pederson is a better coach than Belichek (though he did outcoach him on Sunday). But as a full coaching staff they're better.

Jim Kontopoulos

Northbrook, IL
2018-02-07T00:51:34Z
Congrats to FFI on yet another great season. You guys are the Packers, Steelers, Cowboys, 49ers and Patriots of the fantasy world all wrapped up into one. It is because of you guys that all of us out coach our competition each and every week, year in and year out.

Many thanks for all of your efforts FFI!!
Sign in to add a comment

Fantasy Index