Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Around the NFL

Titans quarterbacks

Not a depth chart fantasy teams need to monitor

The Titans acquired Ryan Tannehill in the offseason, and with Marcus Mariota generally being a disappointment, some wonder if the former Dolphin can push the incumbent for the starting job. Mike Vrabel shot that idea down yesterday, not that it matters much.

Vrabel says that Mariota is the starter and Tannehill the backup, and that Tannehill's job is only to push him. "His job as a backup -- everybody's job as a backup -- is to push the guy in front of him," Vrabel said. "To compete and try to make yourself better and try to make the team better and see how everybody responds."

Depending on how you want to read it, it certainly does seem that Tannehill could make a play for that job. If Tannehill pushes Mariota enough that he's performing better in the preseason, would Vrabel consider a change? It can't be ruled out.

But the history of the two as starting quarterbacks suggests neither would be a fantasy asset.

Over the last five seasons, Mariota and Tannehill are among 20 active quarterbacks to start at least 50 games. Only two guys have put up fewer fantasy points per start than Mariota. Only two other guys have put fewer than Tannehill. Either one looks like a pretty low-impact fantasy signal-caller.

FF PTS PER START, 2014-2018 (MINIMUM 50 STARTS)
PlayerStPYdTDPRYdTDR2PtPts
Andrew Luck54286.62.3117.7.09.0926.1
Aaron Rodgers71264.02.1119.4.13.1424.6
Ben Roethlisberger72301.51.963.0.06.2624.1
Cam Newton75228.91.5737.0.40.0824.0
Drew Brees78299.42.011.7.13.0124.0
Russell Wilson80239.41.8032.8.15.0523.4
Tom Brady76281.12.083.1.07.0423.2
Matt Ryan80290.61.787.4.05.0822.8
Kirk Cousins69274.41.726.8.20.0722.7
Jameis Winston54264.51.5714.2.17.0922.1
Philip Rivers80278.61.912.1.00.0821.9
Matthew Stafford80263.41.607.9.06.0520.8
Blake Bortles73238.11.3823.6.12.1020.7
Eli Manning79261.31.661.6.04.0420.2
Ryan Tannehill56236.21.5513.6.07.0419.9
Andy Dalton72232.51.509.6.15.0619.6
Alex Smith71232.01.2519.8.14.0619.6
Marcus Mariota55216.41.2522.2.22.0519.5
Joe Flacco67249.31.363.7.12.0919.2
Derek Carr78240.21.565.3.01.1219.1

Table uses a scoring system of 1 point for every 20 passing and 10 rushing yards, with 4-point TD passes.

I'm in a couple of best-ball leagues where you draft 28 rounds of players and don't get to make any transactions. And I still have no interest in selecting either quarterback. Probably both guys will make starts this season, and not do very much with those opportunities.

--Andy Richardson

Fantasy Index