Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Factoid

Undrafted rookie wideouts

Can Lance McCutcheon emerge?

When watching preseason football, it's a delicate balancing act of what to pay attention to, and what to downplay. Frequently I need to decide if a big performance in a meaningless game should be mentioned, or dismissed. Which brings us to Lance McCutcheon.

The undrafted rookie wideout out of Montana State had himself a day for the Rams on Saturday, catching 5 passes for 87 yards and 2 touchdowns. It included a 60-yard score where he leapt up to grab it between two defenders (who then collided), and he loped the rest of the way into the end zone. Pretty cool, and it's the kind of performance that may earn him a roster spot, or at least get him in the discussion.

The problem is that the Rams take the idea of not playing starters in the preseason to an extreme. It's not surprising that Cooper Kupp and Allen Robinson didn't play, and Van Jefferson is hurt. But other Rams wideouts not to play included Tutu Atwell, Ben Skowronek and Brandon Powell, in some order the projected 4, 5 and 6 wideouts on the team. Maybe McCutcheon pushes Powell off the roster, but Atwell and Skowronek are making the 53, and one of those guys will likely be the No. 3 early on. Best case scenario is McCutcheon sneaks onto the roster and is worth a pickup in dynasty leagues. But 2022? That would be very unusual.

Undrafted rookies making an impact at running back are a little more likely, and I'll take a look at that history in the next week or so. Undrafted rookies making an impact at wide receiver are really rare.

Table below shows every undrafted rookie wideout to finish in the top 120 (PPR) at the position since 2000. There aren't many, and ones that actually merit a roster spot in typical leagues -- say, finishing in the top 50 -- are even rarer. Doug Baldwin, Keelan Cole, Marlon Brown and Allen Hurns. That's the list.

TOP UNDRAFTED ROOKIE WIDEOUTS, 2000-PRESENT
YearPlayerGTgtRecYdsAvgTDRk
2011Doug Baldwin, Sea.16855178815.5442
2017Keelan Cole, Jac.16834274817.8348
2013Marlon Brown, Balt.14824952410.7748
2014Allen Hurns, Jac.16975167713.3649
2003Dane Looker, St.L.16754749510.5359
2015Seth Roberts, Oak.16553248015.0563
2012Rod Streater, Oak.16743958415.0364
2002Marc Boerigter, K.C.16382042021.0865
2019Steven Sims, Was.1656343109.1666
2016Robby Anderson, NYJ16784258714.0268
2014Taylor Gabriel, Cle.16723662117.3172
2019Preston Williams, Mia.8603242813.4377
2009Danny Amendola, St.L.1463433267.6182
2001Drew Bennett, Ten.14462432913.7182
2015Brandon Coleman, N.O.16493045415.1284
2014Corey Brown, Car.13362129614.1391
2019Jakobi Meyers, N.E.15412635913.8098
2015Adam Humphries, T.B.1340272609.6199
2004Antonio Chatman, G.B.16452224611.2199
2019Greg Ward, Phil.740282549.11101
2002Eric Parker, S.D.9301726815.81103
2003Mike Furrey, St.L.1333201899.50104
2004Chris Horn, K.C.14271517811.91108
2016Jordan Taylor, Den.16251620913.12113
2014Albert Wilson, K.C.12281626016.30113
2011Andrew Hawkins, Cin.13342326311.40113
2016Chester Rogers, Ind.14341927314.40114
2016Geronimo Allison, G.B.10221220216.82116
2015Nick Williams, Atl.1425171599.42116
2015Javontee Herndon, S.D.833241958.10117
2016Jalin Marshall, NYJ10231416211.62119

Some of those guys can overcome those modest beginnings and emerge as viable fantasy starters in future seasons. From the list above, Robby Anderson and Danny Amendola (former Ram!) stand out, and Jakobi Meyers has had his moments. So perhaps McCutcheon should be added in deep dynasty formats. As a senior, he caught 63 passes for 1,219 yards and 9 TDs, and some nice things have been said about him in camp. So maybe.

But would be a real Cinderella story. Which we all love, but be careful about dropping someone with better odds of emerging this season.

--Andy Richardson

Fantasy Index