Fantasy Index

Around the NFL

Sunday morning injury updates

Jacobs gametime decision

It's Sunday morning and football kicks off in a couple of hours, with one pretty concerning overnight report. Adam Schefter is reporting that Josh Jacobs (calf, illness) is a true gametime decision, as opposed to a fake one I guess.

(Ian Rapoport felt the need to put his own twist on things, calling Jacobs "up in the air." Perhaps this was a subtle reference to the fact that Green Bay's flight was delayed 5 hours taking off for Arizona, with the team ultimately switching planes.)

Presumably, because illness seldom keeps players out, the calf injury is the bigger concern here. This is weird, because Jacobs practiced fully on Friday. Either he had a setback with the calf injury during Saturday's walk-through, or the illness is significant. Guys going from full practices on Friday to gametime decision on Saturday night is pretty unusual.

If Jacobs winds up inactive, Emanuel Wlson would be the recommended fill-in. He's been the primary change-of-pace so far, with Chris Brooks the No. 3. If Jacobs sits, I think we'd get about 70-30 (maybe a little more) Wilson, with Brooks the change-of-pace and getting some receiving work.

We had Jacobs as a top-5 option on Friday. Looking at the rankings, if he's inactive, I think Wilson would show up well below that -- 17-20 range. As in, I would not start Wilson over the guys we have ranked 15th-16th (PPR), but would consider it once we're getting to Skattebo-Mason-Dowdle range: bad matchups, committees.

In other news:

  • Tampa Bay wideouts. Both Mike Evans and Emeka Egbuka are questionable with hamstring injuries. Evans is considered likely to play and Egbuka has a real chance to play. My two cents: 1) If you're planning on using either or both, make sure you have a Plan B from the same game -- Sterling Shepard a good one, Tez Johnson a not quite as good one, Isaac TeSlaa a guy I saw suggested somewhere who is not actually viable, do not use a guy who has 5 targets in six games. 2) Evans practiced fully on Saturday. That makes him, in my opinion, safe to use. Egbuka practiced on a limited basis on Saturday. That makes him, in my opinion (sorry, I'm trying to be thorough here), risky to use. He could be active and play limited snaps, for example, or aggravate the injury.

People need to make decisions they are comfortable with for their teams. I have Egbuka in three leagues and he's benched; I'm starting someone else today.

  • From yesterday, Deebo Samuel (heel) is out. Washington's top 2 wideouts should be Luke McCaffrey and Chris Moore. Discussed in the comments of my column yesterday, but to sum: I would start McCaffrey. I think he should be ranked in the 30s as their likely No. 1 wideout. Moore we had ranked in the 60s and he moves up to the 50s, but I personally would be looking at other players on other teams, despite the hugely favorable matchup in Dallas. Also, Zach Ertz (shoulder/calf/old) is expected to play, and should be a top-2 target.

  • D'Andre Swift (groin) is expected to play.

  • Brock Bowers (knee, doubtful) is not expected to play. One might even say he's doubtful to play.

  • Kyler Murray (foot) is not expected to play for Arizona, should be Jacoby Brissett at quarterback, as expected.

  • Christian Kirk (hamstring) has been ruled out for Monday's Texans game at Seattle. Xavier Hutchinson would benefit but is not a recommended option.

  • Stefon Diggs (chest) is expected to play.

If I see any other major developments before the early kickoffs, I'll post in the comments below.

--Andy Richardson

To continue reading this article, please Login or Sign Up at the website
Login Sign Up

24 Reader Comments:

Mark Peterson

Fresno , CA
2025-10-19T13:22:16Z
With Evans coming back from the hammy and playing Monday, would you start him over Whittington. I could insure Evans to an extent with Otton.

Andy Richardson (Fantasy Index)

Port Chester, NY
2025-10-19T13:27:46Z
Rankings good on those WRs. Whittington's game kicks off 8 minutes after you posted your question, so hopefully you made your decision...

Scott Anderson

Las Vegas, NV
2025-10-19T14:09:03Z
Of course Jacobs is the centerpiece of my ppr lineup. I do have Wilson; but if Jacobs sits I have to start 2 of these (we have 2 Flex spots): Skattebo, Wilson, Devonta, Egbuka, Fannin, or Shaheed. Straight projections say Skattebo & Devonta, but... I have come close to dropping Devonta; he's so frustrating.

Rich Wiegard

Frisco, TX
2025-10-19T14:16:35Z
With Cooks on by my options are thin at RB if Jacobs sits. Would you go Woody Marks or should I pick up Wilson which would force me to drop someone…..like Woody Marks or Tre Tucker or Shaheed

Andy Richardson (Fantasy Index)

Port Chester, NY
2025-10-19T14:27:14Z
I’m not sure it’s possible to read Index and not have Jacobs somewhere. I like Wilson more than Marks. Scott I would use 2 from Wilson, Skattebo and Fannin. I’m benching DeVonta, which probably means he’ll have a good game.

Craig Johnson

Channahon, IL
2025-10-19T14:47:13Z
Caleb Williams or Jorden Love. Rainy Windy in Chicago

Andy Richardson (Fantasy Index)

Port Chester, NY
2025-10-19T14:50:38Z
They are close enough in the rankings that I would not argue with switching based on the Chicago weather

Craig Johnson

Channahon, IL
2025-10-19T14:55:06Z
OK 1 more ?
Wendell Robinson Marvin Harrison Romeo Dobbs. 1/2 ppr. Need1

Craig Smith

Humble, TX
2025-10-19T15:10:23Z
Hello again Andy, just woke up to read this mess! Okay, reading carefully in today's article and the weekly FFI, I picked up Wilson to back up Jacobs. Question is, if Jacobs sits, I also have Dowdle and/or Sutton for the flex. So, in order, how should I rank these three guys (Wilson, Dowdle, and Sutton) please?

Jake Frack

Tuckahoe, NY
2025-10-19T15:20:32Z
With the bad weather in Cleveland, would you bench Waddle for Shaheed or DJ Moore in standard scoring?

Scott Fitch

San Mateo, CA
2025-10-19T15:23:43Z
So Otton…does Evans make him a scatch as a flex? I was playing him over Pollard in my flex. Evans coming back maybe doesn’t give me a ton of pause. Egbuka…do I need to pivot? Desperate to hit one of these right.

Andy Richardson (Fantasy Index)

Port Chester, NY
2025-10-19T15:25:00Z
Craig J, rankings are good on those WRs

Craig S, Dowdle and Sutton are virtually identical. For me Wilson is 3rd, but I’d rank him about where Dowdle is. We’re talking fractions of a point separating these guys so just go with the one you feel best about. On my team I’d probably start Dowdle, but it’s more of a hot hand choice than analytical.

Craig Smith

Humble, TX
2025-10-19T15:27:23Z
As always, thank you very much Andy R.!!!

Andy Richardson (Fantasy Index)

Port Chester, NY
2025-10-19T15:33:06Z
Jake apparently weather is a concern in Chicago too. So no

Scott we had Pollard projected a little better than Otton on Friday; when it seemed Evans wouldn’t play. No promises but nothing has occurred to move Otton higher so

Scott Fitch

San Mateo, CA
2025-10-19T15:39:36Z
Nothing is a promise this year except my opponent for the week will get career performances from fringe players and I miss on every flex start…

Craig Johnson

Channahon, IL
2025-10-19T15:54:27Z
Thanks for your expertise!

David Hogshire

Plymouth, MN
2025-10-19T16:08:51Z
I have to choose between Jennings, Mooney and Bam Knight. Any thoughts?

Mike Conway

Nanuet, NY
2025-10-19T16:19:06Z
Any update on Mooney? If he starts would you pay him over Horton? Thanks

Andy Richardson (Fantasy Index)

Port Chester, NY
2025-10-19T16:27:35Z
If Mooney starts I would play him over Seattle's No. 3 who barely makes it onto the Cheat Sheet yes

David of those ugly choices I'd start Jennings and cross my fingers he doesn't pick up yet another injury walking out of the locker room

David Hogshire

Plymouth, MN
2025-10-19T16:39:55Z
Fingers crossed!

Russ Neis

Eagan, MN
2025-10-19T19:04:00Z
calf injury I would suggest dehydration but Jacobs is playing

Mark Rapley

Rosemount, MN
2025-10-19T19:04:25Z
Kittle or Johnston in standard?

Scott Fitch

San Mateo, CA
2025-10-19T23:23:48Z
Waddle….

Andy Richardson (Fantasy Index)

Port Chester, NY
2025-10-20T01:26:39Z
yeah brutal. If memory serves you were debating him versus Ayomanor and Moore, each of whom caught only 2 passes themselves, so I don't think anyone should feel too bad. At least you presumably didn't bench DeVonta (I did in two leagues)
Sign in to add a comment

Fantasy Index