Fantasy Index

Around the NFL

Crusher for Crowell

Achilles injury boosts Jacobs, maybe Warren

Isaiah Crowell has never been a particularly exciting player. But he's been better than you might think, averaging 4.3 yards per carry for his career and going over 1,000 total yards twice for a bad Browns team. But his Oakland season is over before it began: he tore his Achilles at a workout yesterday, and is done for the year.

Obviously, nobody in fantasy leagues was going to be selecting Crowell before Oakland first-rounder Josh Jacobs. Jacobs has more of an all-around game and was a realistic candidate to win the starting job anyway, shunting Crowell into a short-yardage or backup role. But now it looks pretty much certain that Jacobs will be the No. 1, Jalen Richard will pick up some passing down snaps, and just maybe 2018 preseason darling Chris Warren will be assured of a roster spot, if not more.

Warren, some may recall, was an undrafted free agent running back who looked very good for Oakland last preseason. Then he suffered a knee injury that got him placed on IR for the season. But Jon Gruden said "He'll be a guy worth keeping an eye on next year," and now he's one step closer to having an inside running role. Perhaps Oakland's Damien Harris to Jacobs? That might be too optimistic.

Gruden says a lot of things, many of which can be safely ignored. But Warren led the league in rushing last preseason. Does that production mean anything? Warren was undrafted, but flashed some ability in college at Texas and was a combine invite. (Where he proceeded to run a 4.69; hmm.)

I took a look at preseason rushing numbers from the last 10 years. In the table, all running backs who went over 175 yards in August are shown.

PRESEASON RUSHING LEADERS, 2009-2018
YearPlayer Att Yds Avg TD
2010Anthony Dixon, S.F. 743004.14
2018Chris Warren, Oak. 582925.02
2012William Powell, Ariz. 422495.93
2014Lorenzo Taliaferro, Balt. 652433.71
2010Michael Bennett, Oak. 542364.40
2011Kendall Hunter, S.F. 352316.61
2013Khiry Robinson, N.O. 492284.70
2016Mack Brown, Wash. 392275.81
2018Ryan Nall, Chi. 322237.01
2013Jordan Todman, Jac. 292237.72
2016Derrick Henry, Tenn. 342166.43
2013Joseph Randle, Dall. 552153.91
2011Da'Rel Scott, NYG 1421315.22
2014Joe Banyard, Minn. 362125.90
2014Rashad Jennings, NYG 352126.11
2012Rashad Jennings, Jac. 472094.40
2012Nate Eachus, K.C. 342066.11
2013Christine Michael, Sea. 402015.01
2010Cedric Peerman, Cin. 312016.53
2016Rob Kelley, Wash. 381985.21
2018John Kelly, LAR 461974.33
2018Mike Boone, Minn. 491954.01
2016Elijhaa Penny, Ariz. 491954.01
2014Andre Williams, NYG 381955.12
2012Alfred Morris, Wash. 391955.01
2011Armond Smith, Clev. 311926.22
2017Corey Grant, Jac. 221918.71
2014Jeremy Hill, Cin. 411904.60
2011Ryan Mathews, S.D. 241877.82
2012Justin Forsett, Hou. 291856.42
2015Zach Zenner, Det. 351835.22
2010Jonathan Dwyer, Pitt. 391834.71
2017Cameron Artis-Payne, Car. 281806.43
2010Jackie Battle, K.C. 351805.11
2014Fozzy Whittaker, Car. 431794.22
2013David Wilson, NYG 241797.51
2015Jarryd Hayne, S.F. 251757.00
2011Jonathan Dwyer, Pitt. 371754.71

I see a handful of players from the list who went on to have significant seasons, if not careers. Alfred Morris stands out as a guy who caught our eye in the preseason and went on to have some good years. Another Washington back, Rob Kelley, also had his moments.

There are also some early picks who did well in August and continued when the games counted. Jeremy Hill, Derrick Henry, Ryan Mathews. It happens.

Bad break for Crowell, but maybe this will be opportunity Warren needs to carve out a decent role in the offense.

--Andy Richardson

10 Reader Comments:

Dennis Salisbury

Cranston, RI
2019-05-01T13:35:10Z
Kiddin me Crowell? It blows my mind how these players today get hurt on non-contact injuries in regular workouts. Certainly makes Jacobs #1 pick for sure in dynasty.

Andy Richardson

Port Chester, NY
2019-05-01T14:10:27Z
Yeah, I don't think Crowell's one-year deal was going to keep anyone from selecting Jacobs first in rookie drafts. None of the ones I've seen thus far, anyway.

Dennis Salisbury

Cranston, RI
2019-05-01T14:27:04Z
I think we are going to get a wide variance beginning in the middle of the 1st round of these rookie dynasty drafts this year...Jacobs is being pegged as pick # 1 almost by default? Strange year for rooks...should be quite interesting to say the least.

Andy Richardson

Port Chester, NY
2019-05-01T14:55:35Z
Just going on the drafts and ADP I've seen -- it's easy to find by searching on Twitter -- Jacobs and Harry are the clear top 2; sometimes Harry over Jacobs. But no agreement on Sanders vs. Montgomery, and some are even sticking a wideout at No. 3: Hardman, Brown, Metcalf. Tough year.

John Evans

Rochester, MN
2019-05-01T15:34:42Z
It’s actually a decent year to have a late pick in a rookie draft. I’m picking 12 in one league after winning it last year, and honestly there doesn’t seem to be a substantial difference between 2-14 or so. I should be able to land a decent prospect at any position of desire.

Ian Allan

Seattle, WA
2019-05-01T15:36:22Z
I think Crowell's a good player. He's the only running back in the league who's had a 50-yard run in each of the last four years. He ran for a team-record 219 yards against Denver last year. He hasn't been a consistent, reliable producer, but he's always been working at the disadvantage of playing on bad teams. (His last four teams have gone 8-56 -- an average of 2-14 per season). After he scored against his original team last year, he celebrated by using the ball as toilet paper, then throwing it into the stands. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAjJsZTXhkM Too bad we're not going to see him compete against Josh Jacobs, because I think Crowell might have been the better of those two backs.

Ben Hogevoll

Siletz, OR
2019-05-01T15:46:39Z
Maybe the Raiders bring Doug Martin back?

Paul Desimone

Hayward, CA
2019-05-01T18:22:02Z
Really sorry to see this. Really a crummy break. And I agree he'd have had a good shot at outperforming Jacobs, had it come down to performance and not draft status or being a bargain signing.

Andy Richardson

Port Chester, NY
2019-05-01T19:29:08Z
Ben with the impressive call; Raiders re-sign Martin

DAVID DIGREGORIO

Norristown, PA
2019-05-02T13:00:11Z
Oakland signed Doug Martin.
Sign in to add a comment

Fantasy Index