Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Factoid

T.J. Watt

Big year not enough to unseat Donald

The NFL handed out its 2020 awards last night, a fairly dull affair with taped messages from players and (obviously) no cheering fans. There was nothing particularly surprising with most of the results, but there was some controversy, if you asked J.J. Watt.

Aaron Donald won Defensive Player of the Year, again, and it didn't sit well with Watt. He took to Twitter to make the case for brother T.J., who finished with better numbers than Donald in virtually every defensive category. Stats aren't everything -- they can't always measure the impact a player has -- but if people are going to use stats to make the case for Aaron Rodgers, say, over Josh Allen or Patrick Mahomes, the same can be done with defensive players.

And Watt is correct to note that the Steelers pass rusher had more sacks (15-13.5), tackles (53-41), tackles for losses (23-12), quarterback pressures (55-42) and hits on the quarterback (41-26) than Donald. Fumbles was the only area that Donald out-produced Watt (4-2) last season.

Watt's got a bias, but he makes a pretty good point. Defensive Player of the Year or not, his brother just completed one of the best seasons by any defensive player this century.

Over the last 20 years, 35 players have finished with at least 15 sacks and 50 tackles. J.J. Watt did it four times, one of only two players (the other is DeMarcus Ware) to do it more than twice. Only one guy did it in 2020: T.J. Watt.

15-PLUS SACKS AND 50-PLUS TACKLES, 2001-PRESENT
YearPlayerTmSkSoloAstComb
2020T.J. WattPIT15.0431053
2019Cameron JordanNOR15.5371653
2019Chandler JonesARI19.0421153
2019Shaquil BarrettTAM19.5451358
2018Aaron DonaldLAR20.5411859
2018J.J. WattHOU16.0471461
2017Chandler JonesARI17.052759
2015J.J. WattHOU17.5571976
2015Khalil MackOAK15.0572077
2014J.J. WattHOU20.5591978
2014Justin HoustonKAN22.060969
2013Greg HardyCAR15.0392059
2013Robert MathisIND19.5441559
2013Robert QuinnSTL19.050757
2012Aldon SmithSFO19.5501666
2012Cameron WakeMIA15.0381553
2012J.J. WattHOU20.5691281
2012Von MillerDEN18.5551368
2011DeMarcus WareDAL19.5481058
2011Jared AllenMIN22.0481866
2011Jason Pierre-PaulNYG16.5662086
2010DeMarcus WareDAL15.5561066
2008DeMarcus WareDAL20.0691584
2008James HarrisonPIT16.06734101
2007Jared AllenKAN15.556965
2006Aaron KampmanGNB15.5593089
2006Shawne MerrimanSDG17.0491463
2005Derrick BurgessOAK16.052658
2003Adewale OgunleyeMIA15.0432164
2003Michael StrahanNYG18.5601575
2003Simeon RiceTAM15.045550
2002Jason TaylorMIA18.5462470
2002Simeon RiceTAM15.541950
2001Michael StrahanNYG22.5611273
2001Peter BoulwareBAL15.0442266

Search engines at pro-football-reference.com used to compile this table.

Anyone who watched the Rams play this year (or in recent years) is aware of how much of a game-changer Donald is. But T.J. Watt is also pretty good, and comes off his best season. His brother has a point.

--Andy Richardson

Fantasy Index