Fantasy Index

Podcast

September 13 episode of the Fantasy Index Podcast

Download the new episode or listen below

A special guest joins Moishe Steigmann and Justin Eleff to play Supply by Demand in Week 2. Play along at home and win a plaque from Affordable Trophies.

You can download the September 13, 2022 podcast directly or subscribe on iTunes.

You may also listen to the episode directly on this page:

50 Reader Comments:

Justin Eleff

Alexandria, VA
2022-09-13T22:29:42Z
SUPPLY BY DEMAND
Week 2 deadline - Friday, September 16, 11:59 PM on the Late Coast

You choose:

Derek Carr (Moishe) - OR - Trevor Lawrence (Justin);

Nick Chubb (Moishe) - OR - D'Andre Swift (Justin);

Justin Jefferson (Justin) - OR - Cooper Kupp (Moishe); and

Taysom Hill (Justin) - OR - O.J. Howard (Moishe) (yes, really)

Mike Nobach

Marysville, WA
2022-09-13T23:09:52Z
Carr
Swift
Jefferson
Hill

Ben Hogevoll

Siletz, OR
2022-09-13T23:26:13Z
Carr-Chubb-Jefferson-Hill

Craig Leedy

Sacramento, CA
2022-09-14T00:00:49Z
my picks=Carr, Chubb, Kupp, T.Hill

LEE STONE

New Kensington, PA
2022-09-14T00:04:15Z
QB - Carr
RB - Swift
WR - Kupp
TE - Hill

Chad Henslee

Nederland, TX
2022-09-14T01:23:56Z
Carr
Swift
Jefferson
Howard

Gary Bauer

Marinette, WI
2022-09-14T01:48:31Z
Lawrence
Swift
Jefferson
Howard

Brandon Nobach

Spokane, WA
2022-09-14T02:51:11Z
Was fun to see the sausage get made and contrary to what we spoke about on the pod quite enjoyable to listen in and only a few screw ups really.

I’ll go
Carr (for the DJs)
Swift
Cooper Kupp (for the heart)
And Hill

So another split this week for Moishe and Justin.

Ken Nobach

Burlington, WA
2022-09-14T02:52:18Z
Qb Carr
Rb Chubb
We Jefferson
Te Hill

Dave Cohen

Brooklyn, NY
2022-09-14T04:34:52Z
Carr
Swift
Jefferson
Hill

Blair Nobach

Everett, WA
2022-09-14T05:48:36Z
Carr Swift Jefferson Howard

Christopher Bowen

Louisville, KY
2022-09-14T09:44:00Z
Lawrence
Swift
Jefferson
Howard

Vincent Kellogg

Phoenix, AZ
2022-09-14T09:58:34Z
Carr
Swift
Kupp
Howard

Dan Bowman

Liberty, MO
2022-09-14T15:56:13Z
Carr
Chubb
Jefferson
Howard

Todd Blinn

Obetz, OH
2022-09-14T17:45:40Z
Carr
Chubb
Jefferson
Hill

Kevin Dallas

Covington, KY
2022-09-14T18:14:45Z
Carr
Swift
Kupp
Hill

Scott Anderson

Las Vegas, NV
2022-09-14T18:23:55Z
Another boring ass episode to skip. Wake me when Ian is back on

Patrick Daniali

Glendale, AZ
2022-09-14T21:21:36Z
Carr, Chubb, Jefferson, Hill

Ernest Freund

Annandale, VA
2022-09-14T21:52:18Z
Carr
Chubb
Jefferson
Howard

Dwight Johnson

Columbia, MD
2022-09-14T22:43:02Z
If you want to be a star,
At quarterback take DEREK CARR.
To win a real fantastic gift
Your running back's D'ANDRE SWIFT.
This game will be a lot more fun
If you chose JUSTIN JEFFERSON.
No one can call you "craven coward"
When you select old O.J. HOWARD.
If you think Justin's acting strange
It's just his turn to diaper change.

Ernest Freund

Annandale, VA
2022-09-14T22:46:13Z
Carr
Chubb
Jefferson
Howard

Anthony Hoffman

Kapaa, HI
2022-09-15T00:46:42Z
Mr Lawrence
Mr Chubb
Mr Jefferson
Mr Hill
Sorry the shipping is gonna be expensive to Hawaii for my plaque…

Shaun Hawkins

Albany, GA
2022-09-15T02:28:11Z
I'll have:
Carr
Chubb
Jefferson
OJ

Shaun Hawkins

Albany, GA
2022-09-15T02:30:37Z
Wondering if the Nobachs all put in different combinations of picks to increase the odds that one of them wins. Like a lotto pool. hmmm.

FRANK NAPPO

Buffalo, NY
2022-09-15T04:36:01Z
Lawrence
Swift
Kupp
Hill

Justin Eleff

Alexandria, VA
2022-09-15T10:17:18Z
I like that Scott not only listened to enough of the episode to know he should skip it, but then came back to say so. Feels like an excellent use of his time.

Justin Eleff

Alexandria, VA
2022-09-15T10:20:08Z
Shaun: Multiple Nobachs have had perfect lineups in the same week, I believe. But games of skill are more the Fortiers' forte. Where the Nobachs truly crush is at Random.org.

Justin Eleff

Alexandria, VA
2022-09-15T10:28:55Z
NEW RULE inspired by podcast legend Dwight Johnson: any perfect lineup submitted *in verse* goes into the random drawing more than once. I'll think through exactly how to reward the extra effort.

Joel Van Diggelen

Vernon Hills, IL
2022-09-15T12:11:36Z
Derek Carr
D’Andre Swift
Justin Jefferson
OJ Howard
?‍♂️

MATT JACKSON

Norwalk, CT
2022-09-15T12:24:58Z
Carr
Chubb
Kupp
Hill

Jerry Fortier

2022-09-15T15:33:21Z
Carr
Chubb
Kupp
Howard

John Kunka

Orland Park, IL
2022-09-15T16:50:47Z
Derek Carr
D'Andre Swift
Cooper Kupp
Taysom Hill

Holihandicapper Holizna

Canton, GA
2022-09-15T16:59:56Z
Carr
Chubb
Jefferson
Howard

Ken Edwards

Salinas, CA
2022-09-15T22:21:10Z
Moishe went with CARR, he will go far.
Swift and my Lions may get the “Dub”, but I have to go with CHUBB
Supply by Demand takes some skill, I have to go with HILL
Kupp took me to the Listeners League Super Bowl in 2021, but this week I go with JEFFERSON.

CARR / CHUBB / HILL / JEFFERSON
#evilgenius

Tim Yoko

Murfreesboro, TN
2022-09-16T04:10:27Z
Carr
Chubb
Jefferson
Howard

Justin Eleff

Alexandria, VA
2022-09-16T04:18:57Z
Coming next week, obv: the most unrhymable names we can think of.

Jack Sandler

Oldsmar, FL
2022-09-16T09:02:25Z
BREAKING NEWS: Red Challenge Flag Thrown for Week 1 by "Jack Sandler of Oldsmar Florida." Due to the Week 1 Schedule Change in which Supply by Demand came out on Friday due to Ian's 30th Wedding Anniversary...

Jack Sandler was controversially suspended from the "Week 1, Fantasy Index Podcast, Supply By Demand, Perfect Lineup, Affordable Trophies, Random Drawing for a Plaque Contest" because he couldn't get to the exciting 2022 Premiere 'Justin/Moishe' Episode until Saturday, September 10th AFTER both the Friday, September 9th premiere date and the 3 am EST, Sept 10th deadline.

During his national interview about the controversy, Jack Sandler was quoted as saying, "with the unusual schedule reversal of the 'Justin/Moishe Show' moving to Friday BEHIND the 'Justin/Ian Show' which was as controversial as ABC mismanagement of moving the top rated Mork and Mindy from Thursday nights to Sunday nights in 1979 vs. All in the Family and causing a record Nielsen rating plunge, the Week 1, Supply by Demand picks deadline should've been extended until the Sunday, 1 PM EST kickoffs. I will look forward to my free entry into the Week 2 random drawing after the official word comes from the podcast replay officials in New York." :)

Kidding.

I was just happy to have been mentioned on the big, national broadcast again even in controversy. And to prove I listened to the entire Week 2 podcast coming in at over 1 hour and 22 minutes, I was happy to hear my Week 1 tardiness reprimanded a 2nd time in the final seconds. 'There’s no such thing as bad publicity. Bad Press is Better Than No Press.' - P .T. Barnum.

My favorite appearance on the big Justin/Moishe Show, however, remains my 2021 Random Drawing Supply by Demand Trophy Victory. :)

In any event - moving forward- here are my Week 2 picks submitted well before the Week 2 deadline:

And just in case my 'Week 1 non-drawing entry challenge' comes in as either 'confirmed or stands as called' instead of 'reversed-' which would allow me a guaranteed spot in the Week 2 random drawing- I'm also going for the extra drawing entries by submitting my Week 2 picks within the new "Extra Effort...goes into the random drawing more than once, *In Poetic Verse Format:'

THUS, HERE ARE MY WEEK 2 PICKS IN POETIC FORM:

Even though everyone seems to be picking him
After Week 1, Mahomes picked the Cardinals' defense APART
Going for Trevor Lawrence over DEREK CARR in Week 2
My conclusions are it just wouldn't be SMART

THUS: PICK 1: DEREK CARR (Moishe)

I see a lot of entries going with Chubb as their RB choice
As he should easily run wild over the pathetic New York JETS
But since he's the heart of a much better Lions Offense
For Week 2, D'ANDRE SWIFT is where I'm placing my BETS

THUS: PICK 2: D'ANDRE SWIFT (Moishe)

Justin Jefferson is the league's best player
But in Week 2, I'll be rooting that he gets a little beat UP
Because my fantasy team's forced to play the Eagles DST
And versus Atlanta, it's big numbers for Cooper KUPP

THUS: PICK 3: COOPER KUPP (Moishe)

And, finally, in the battle of the 40th vs. the 41st best tight end
In which I'm sure both participants will provide fans with a huge THRILL
I agree with Justin that OJ Howard will not show up for a Week 2 sequel
Thus, I'm going with the likely red zone QB success of Taysom HILL

THUS: Pick 4: TAYSOM HILL (Justin)

-Jack the Rapper

Justin Eleff

Alexandria, VA
2022-09-16T15:16:01Z
Good lord, that was easily more effort than we've ever put into *recording* an episode. I have to overrule the Week 1 deadline objection -- based mostly on your own confession, what with the would-have-been perfect lineup immediately following a disclaiming "Missed the deadline but I'd have picked" -- but the time sunk into this Week 2 submission has not gone unnoticed or unappreciated. More on that next week.

Gary Fortier

Marietta, GA
2022-09-16T16:48:09Z
I'm not going to even try to compete with Jack's diatribe! Instead I'll just pick the winning lineup:
Carr
Swift
Kupp
Howard

Kevin Cox

Munster, IN
2022-09-16T17:35:55Z
Carr
Swift
Kupp
Hill

Moishe Steigmann

Milwaukee, WI
2022-09-16T18:18:27Z
These are unreal. Thank you, everyone for all the joy you have brought me reading these poems (and the one treatise)!

@Justin: you're in trouble this week. I have one of the skilled fantasy footballers (Jerry Fortier) all-in on Team Moishe!

Justin Eleff

Alexandria, VA
2022-09-16T20:09:26Z
Eh, it's all #teamNobach all the time here.

William Fortier

Cumberland, RI
2022-09-16T22:41:53Z
Who is now acting in Justin’s place and where in the world is the real Justin Eleff? I will concede that Brandon Nobach did a nice job on the podcast this week, but this co-managing the Diaper Jockeys and #teamNobach is too much! Like Brandon’s daughter seeing Justin’s daughter for the first time; all this Nobach love has me spitting up all over myself!

In the meantime SBD goes on:
Carr
Chubb
Kupp
Hill

Josh Fortier

Boston, MA
2022-09-16T22:57:07Z
Lawrence
Jefferson
Chubb
Howard

David Fortier

2022-09-17T00:44:20Z
Derek Carr

Nick Chubb

Justin Jefferson

Taysom Hill

David Leonard

Ormond Beach, FL
2022-09-17T01:49:02Z
Carr
Chubb
Kupp
Howard

Rich Micheli

Washington, DC
2022-09-17T03:19:37Z
Trevor Lawrence
D'Andre Swift
Justin Jefferson
Taysom Hill

Justin Eleff

Alexandria, VA
2022-09-17T03:19:42Z
After one week it would be fair of Brandon to wonder if I am sabotaging the Diaper Jockeys. (And of Moishe to wonder if I should be the one not playing any lineup leagues.) But whatever my fleeting allegiances, always good to see the Fortier clan in the comments here.

Paul Deutsch

Sioux Falls, SD
2022-09-17T12:13:08Z
《Late entry》
Derek Carr
Nick Chubb
Justin Jefferson
Taysom Hill

William Gross

St Petersburg, FL
2022-09-17T13:11:07Z
Lawrence
Swift
Jefferson
Hill
Sign in to add a comment

Fantasy Index