Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Dynasty Leagues

Long-term QB rankings

Tagovailoa should be back next week

Tua Tagovailoa has cleared the concussion protocol, according to an NFL Network report. He won’t play this week, but he’s expected to be in the starting lineup in Week 7.

This makes Tagovailoa an intriguing short-term prospect. The Dolphins next week are hosting Pittsburgh, which is struggling defensively. The following week, Miami is at Detroit, which has been even worse. I would think Tagovailoa will throw multiple touchdowns in both of those games.

Looking longer term (which is where I’m putting the focus here), Tagovailoa is in a good spot in that he’s working with a pair of elite wide receivers, as well as an innovative coaching staff that seems more able than most to design pass plays that challenge secondaries.

On the downside, durability is a huge issue. He’s a smaller guy, and he might be more prone to concussions than other players. If Tagovailoa in a couple of weeks were to suffer another head injury, where would that put his career?

If I were walking into a dynasty draft today, Tagovailoa wouldn’t be one of the first 10 quarterbacks I would consider. But I think he becomes a possibility just outside that range. He’s a lot younger than guys like Stafford, Wilson, Carr, Brady and Rodgers. Youngsters like Justin Fields and Trey Lance (and even Malik Willis) bring a lot more to the table as runners, but none of them have shown much ability yet to operate successfully as passers.

Below see my top 50 dynasty league quarterbacks. This is operating under the assumption that we’ve got a 12-team league, with each carrying about three quarterbacks. I’m assuming standard scoring, and working under the assumption that teams would be able to hold players indefinitely.

Rookies tagged with black dots.

DYNASTY LEAGUE QUARTERBACKS
RkTmPlayerAge
1.LACJustin Herbert24
2.BUFJosh Allen26
3.KCPatrick Mahomes27
4.BALLamar Jackson25
5.CINJoe Burrow25
6.PHIJalen Hurts24
7.CLEDeshaun Watson27
8.MINKirk Cousins34
9.DALDak Prescott29
10.JACTrevor Lawrence23
11.ARIKyler Murray25
12.LARMatthew Stafford34
13.GBAaron Rodgers38
14.MIATua Tagovailoa24
15.DENRussell Wilson33
16.LVDerek Carr31
17.TBTom Brady45
18.PIT• Kenny Pickett24
19.CHIJustin Fields23
20.SFTrey Lance22
21.NYGDaniel Jones25
22.NEMac Jones24
23.DETJared Goff28
24.SEAGeno Smith32
25.TENRyan Tannehill34
26.WASCarson Wentz29
27.NOJameis Winston28
28.NYJZach Wilson23
29.SFJimmy Garoppolo30
30.HOUDavis Mills23
31.ATL• Desmond Ridder23
32.TEN• Malik Willis23
33.INDMatt Ryan37
34.ATLMarcus Mariota28
35.PHIGardner Minshew27
36.MIATeddy Bridgewater29
37.CLEJacoby Brissett29
38.BALTyler Huntley24
39.CARBaker Mayfield27
40.GBJordan Love23
41.NYGTyrod Taylor33
42.NOAndy Dalton34
43.INDSam Ehlinger24
44.SEADrew Lock25
45.DALCooper Rush28
46.NE• Bailey Zappe23
47.BUFCase Keenum34
48.WASTaylor Heinicke29
49.PITMitchell Trubisky28
50.NYJJoe Flacco37

I turn my attention to dynasty leagues each Saturday, rotating between the four notable positions. To see previous versions, use the “past issues” navigation box.

Last week: Wide receivers.

Next week: Running backs.

—Ian Allan

Fantasy Index