Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Factoid

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Can Doug Martin get back on track?

Doug Martin was pretty awful last year, averaging only 2.9 yards per carry. Is there any chance of this guy turning things around? Some of the problems were no doubt tied to the offensive line, but I remember journeyman Jacquizz Rodgers coming in to close out the San Diego game and outplaying him.

Martin is suspended for the first three games of the season, and I’m not confident he’ll even be on their team. He’s due $7 million, and he’s not worth that. I expect they’ll release him or force him to take a hefty pay cut. They could draft a replacement or sign one of the many free agent running backs looking for work. Adrian Peterson was working out with Jameis Winston recently, but they say he’s not in their plans.

Martin is 28 and was an effective back in 2015, so I suppose there’s some chance of him being a decent running back somewhere. But let’s look at some of the historical numbers. Specifically, how often does a player carry the ball at least 100 times, averaging under 3.0 yards per carry, then come back the next year and put together a good season?

In the last 20 years, there have been only 22 candidates to look at, so I’ve expanded it to backs averaging under 3.2 yards per attempt. That gives us 45 running backs, and we can then look at how those players did in their next season. (And as we move up to 3.2 per attempt, we pick up another pair from 2016 – Todd Gurley and Thomas Rawls.)

Only five of these 45 players (the year after their terrible seasons) ran for 800-plus yards. So either they didn’t get better, or they continued to be held back by the lesser offense around them.

Three of the 45 went over 1,000 yards and that includes two had been under 3.0 yards per carry – Marshall Faulk with injuries and a poor offensive line in Indianapolis in 1997, and Eddie George in Tennessee in 2002.

Overall, the success rate on these kind of backs has been pretty darn low. They’ve tended to stay bad. Thirteen of the 45 backs didn’t even play the next year, and another 18 hardly played (finishing with not more than 40 carries).

We’ll see what Martin’s situation is heading into training camp, but right now I’m not optimistic he’ll make much of an impact.

On this chart, the players are ordered by the crappiest of their yards per carry (the year before the season shown). Chester Taylor averaged only 2.4 yards per attempt – the lowest – so he’s listed first. When you get down to 2014 Trent Richardson, you’re getting the last of the guys under 3.0. The bottom half of the list, you’re seeing the guys between 3.0 and 3.2

RUNNING BACKS AVERAGING UNDER 3.2 PER CARRY
YearPlayer AttYards AvgTDPrevious Year
2011Chester Taylor, Ariz.20773.91112-267-2.40-3
2000Natrone Means, Car.00--0112-277-2.47-4
2009Chris Perry (DNP)--------104-269-2.60-2
2003Jonathan Wells, Hou.5142.80197-529-2.68-3
2014Willis McGahee (DNP)--------138-377-2.73-2
1998Larry Centers, Ariz.311103.50101-276-2.73-1
2013Rashad Jennings, Oak.1637334.56101-283-2.80-2
2009Tim Hightower, Ariz.1435984.28143-399-2.80-10
2000Byron Hanspard (DNP)--------136-383-2.81-1
2007Kevan Barlow (DNP)--------131-370-2.82-6
2002• Warrick Dunn, Atl.2309274.07158-447-2.82-3
2002James Jackson, Clev.12544.50195-554-2.84-2
1998Darnell Autry (DNP)--------112-319-2.84-1
2000Adrian Murrell, Wash.20502.50193-553-2.86-0
2014Bernard Pierce, Balt.933663.92152-436-2.86-2
2006Marcel Shipp, Ariz.17412.44157-451-2.87-0
2017Doug Martin, T.B.????144-421-2.90-3
2008Rudi Johnson, Det.762373.11170-497-2.90-3
2001Travis Prentice, Minn.1413.92173-512-2.95-7
1997• Marshall Faulk, Ind.2641,0544.07198-587-2.96-7
2002• Eddie George, Tenn.3431,1653.412315-939-2.98-5
2001Darnell Autry (DNP)--------112-334-2.98-3
2014Trent Richardson, Ind.1595193.33188-563-2.99-3
1997Darick Holmes, Buff.221064.82189-571-3.02-4
2000Joe Montgomery, NYG14--1115-348-3.02-3
2006Stephen Davis, St.L.401774.40180-549-3.04-12
1997Errict Rhett, T.B.31963.13176-539-3.06-3
2014Ray Rice (DNP)--------214-660-3.08-4
2001Jermaine Fazande (DNP)--------119-368-3.09-2
2002Lamar Smith, Car.2097373.57313-968-3.09-6
2015Alfred Blue, Hou.1836983.82169-528-3.10-2
2012Thomas Jones (DNP)--------153-478-3.10-0
2015Ben Tate (DNP)--------119-371-3.10-4
2000Abdul-Karim al-Jabbar, Ind.1-2-2.00143-445-3.11-1
2006T.J. Duckett, Wash.381323.52121-380-3.14-8
1998Leeland McElroy (DNP)--------135-424-3.14-2
1998• Abdul-Karim al-Jabbar, Mia.2709603.66283-892-3.15-15
2000• Warrick Dunn, T.B.2481,1334.68195-616-3.15-0
2000Cecil Collins (DNP)--------131-414-3.16-2
2014Rashard Mendenhall (DNP)--------217-687-3.16-8
2000Curtis Enis, Chi.36842.31287-916-3.19-3
2003Leon Johnson, S.D.4266.50103-329-3.19-1
2008Warrick Dunn, T.B.1867864.22227-720-3.20-4
2011Jahvid Best, Det.843904.62171-555-3.20-4
2017Todd Gurley, L.A.????278-885-3.20-6
2017Thomas Rawls, Sea.????109-349-3.20-3
2015Toby Gerhart, Jac.20442.20101-326-3.20-2
2013LaRod Stephens-Howling, Pitt.6193.20111-357-3.20-4

—Ian Allan

Fantasy Index