Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Around the NFL

Jimmy Garoppolo

What does future hold for Niners QB?

The 49ers traded up to the No. 3 pick in the draft yesterday, which they'll use on a quarterback. But they maintain that Jimmy Garoppolo will be their starting quarterback in 2021. Should anyone believe them?

Keeping Garoppolo and starting him in 2021 does make some sense. The team has playoff aspirations -- it was in the Super Bowl just over a year ago -- and whichever quarterback they draft will need some grooming and development. If they trade Garoppolo, they'd either be throwing their rookie into the fire in Week 1 (in a division that features some of the league's best pass rushers, including Aaron Donald and now J.J. Watt), or be starting Nick Mullens, which no one really wants to see.

So while Garoppolo might not be happy about suddenly being cast as a bridge quarterback, that might well be his lot this season. Ideally, from his standpoint, playing well enough that some team will be enamored enough of him to hand him the reins to its starting job in 2022.

There's also the distinct possibility that San Francisco is saying it won't trade Garoppolo because it doesn't have a lot of choice in the matter. Garoppolo will make around $26 million this season, and it's hard to argue he's worth it. Does anyone want to acquire him and pay him that kind of money? The guy has proven to be a pretty mediocre quarterback.

Including the playoffs, Garoppolo has started 35 games since 2016 (2 for the Patriots, 33 for San Francisco). He's averaged 236 passing yards and just under 1.5 TD passes per game. Project those numbers out over a full season, and you have a starting quarterback who throws for 3,775 yards and 23 touchdowns. In fantasy football terms, that would rank him 21st among the 25 quarterbacks who started most of the season a year ago. That's a quarterback any team (except apparently the Giants, still committed to Daniel Jones) would be looking to replace.

GAROPPOLO CAREER VERSUS 2020 QUARTERBACKS
YearPlayerPassPaTDRunRuTDFFPts
2020Josh Allen, Buff.4544374218473.5
2020Kyler Murray, Ariz.39712681911450.4
2020Aaron Rodgers, G.B.4299481493440.2
2020Patrick Mahomes, K.C.4740383082437.8
2020Deshaun Watson, Hou.4823334443437.5
2020Russell Wilson, Sea.4212405132435.9
2020Tom Brady, T.B.46334063410.2
2020Ryan Tannehill, Ten.3819332667398.5
2020Justin Herbert, LAC4336312345398.2
2020Lamar Jackson, Balt.27572610057386.3
2020Kirk Cousins, Min.4265351561384.8
2020Matt Ryan, Atl.458126922356.2
2020Derek Carr, L.V.4103271403347.1
2020Ben Roethlisberger, Pitt.380333110327.2
2020Matthew Stafford, Det.4084261120323.4
2020Jared Goff, LAR395220994313.5
2020Cam Newton, N.E.2657859212309.5
2020Baker Mayfield, Cle.3563261651308.2
2020Teddy Bridgewater, Car.3733152795306.5
2020Philip Rivers, Ind.416924-80305.6
16-'20Jimmy Garoppolo, S.F.377523641293.2
2020Carson Wentz, Phil.2620162765262.6
2020Drew Brees, N.O.294224-22254.9
2020Drew Lock, Den.2933161603246.6
2020Daniel Jones, NYG2943114231241.4

Of the other six guys in Career Garoppolo area, two retired, one was traded away, and two others (Bridgewater and Lock) are on teams that would like to draft their next franchise quarterback atop this year's draft. I think the Broncos might very well swing a trade with the Falcons, sitting at No. 4, to get up there (NFC South rival Carolina seems less likely). The Giants are giving Jones another season, with improved weapons around him, but a year from now they might very well be replacing him too.

So I believe San Francisco, at least today, when they say they aren't trading Garoppolo. Mainly because I don't know that anyone is actually calling them expressing an interest in acquiring him, even with him having quarterbacked them to a Super Bowl not so long ago. Not at his salary, and not based on his NFL career thus far.

--Andy Richardson

Fantasy Index